Before a Pittsburgh police officer punched, kneed and kicked a man during an arrest outside a South Side bar early Sunday, the man told police he had a gun and implied he was going to shoot up the bar, according to a report written by the arresting officer.

The end of the altercation between the man and two police officers was caught on video by Damian Trott, a 24-year-old bystander who happened on the scene about 2 a.m. outside The Flats On Carson at 1500 E. Carson St. The 10-second video shows Officer Raymond Toomey knee and kick 26-year-old Nathan Stanley III in the face while the man is on the ground.

Nathan Stanley III

Officer Toomey said in his report that he feared Mr. Stanley was reaching for his waistband to retrieve a firearm when he delivered the blows, but Mr. Trott’s video shows Mr. Stanley had both hands flat on the ground in front of him when Officer Toomey kicked him in the face.

Advertise with us

Two city agencies and a police review board are investigating.

“I’m troubled any time that I see that there’s a need for any escalation of force with the public,” Mayor Bill Peduto said Monday. “But sometimes it does become warranted if there’s a threat. We’ll determine during these next several weeks if there was a threat that would have warranted the escalation of force.”

Mr. Peduto said the officers would remain on duty pending the investigations. He said he would not comment on the case “until there has been an investigation.”

He asked the city Office of Municipal Investigations to look into the incident, which also is under review by the police bureau and Pittsburgh’s Citizen Police Review Board. They will use Mr. Trott’s video and security camera footage from the area in their investigations, the mayor said.

Mr. Trott’s video shows Officer Shenandoah Welsh and Officer Toomey struggling with Mr. Stanley, who is on the ground. It does not capture the preceding minutes, which Officer Toomey detailed in a criminal complaint filed Sunday.

Advertise with us

Officer Toomey said he was moonlighting at the bar when a security guard said a man had threatened the guard with a gun. Officer Toomey found Mr. Stanley outside, where he appeared to be heavily intoxicated, the complaint said.

Mr. Stanley said he had a gun and was going to “shoot ya’ll up,” apparently referring to the bar, Officer Toomey wrote. Mr. Stanley also pantomimed shooting at the bar, according to the complaint.

He then reached for his waistband, prompting Officer Toomey to shove Mr. Stanley away from the bar, the complaint said. Officer Toomey said Mr. Stanley grabbed a sign post with one hand and continued to reach for his waistband with the other.

Officer Toomey could not pry Mr. Stanley away from the post, according to the complaint. As Officer Welsh arrived, Officer Toomey punched Mr. Stanley four times — twice in the man’s “midsection” and twice in the face — then got him to the ground by sweeping his legs out from under him.

The officers struggled to handcuff Mr. Stanley, but were unsuccessful. Officer Toomey said he then delivered the kick and knee strike “out of fear that [Stanley’s] arms were underneath his body because he was still attempting to reach towards his waistband for a weapon.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Trott’s footage shows that Mr. Stanley’s hands were flat on the ground in front of him when Officer Toomey kicked him. Pittsburgh Public Safety Director Wendell Hissrich said the recording illustrates “the end of an incident — but we don’t know what happened prior.”

“In this day and age, you take threats serious, whether it be a terrorism threat or what people say,” Mr. Hissrich said. “We’ll have to take a look at the whole, entire picture. It’s just too early in the investigation for us to make any type of decision or ruling.”

Sonya Toler, a police spokeswoman, would not confirm whether officers recovered a firearm from Mr. Stanley, but the complaint notes that no “illegal contraband” or “means of escape” were found, and Mr. Stanley does not face weapons charges.

At the Citizen Police Review Board, executive director Elizabeth Pittinger said it was too soon to say whether the officers used reasonable force.

“I don’t know why they had to kick him in the head,” Ms. Pittinger added. “That’s a question that I think we all have, and that’s what we’re going to try to establish an answer to.”

Advertise with us

Punches, kicks and knee strikes are all “sanctioned control techniques” that the police bureau allows when suspects resist, according to a 2016 report published by the bureau.

Such strikes are considered mid-range on the department’s use-of-force continuum, a five-tier system that ranks responses by intensity. The continuum begins with verbal commands, followed by grabbing, pushing, pulling and forcible handcuffing in the second tier.

The third tier includes pepper spray, kicks, punches and strikes. Taser use and police canines appear in the fourth tier, and the final tier includes only the use of a police firearm.

Officers used punches, kicks and strikes in 10 percent of all reported use-of-force incidents between 2010 and 2015, according to the report. About 57 percent of use-of-force incidents involved black suspects, the report said. About 26 percent of the city population is black.

Officers eventually handcuffed Mr. Stanley, who is black, and took him to the Allegheny County Jail. He was charged with aggravated assault, public drunkenness and disorderly conduct. He posted $10,000 bond and faces a preliminary hearing May 18.

Advertise with us

The incident is not the first time Mr. Stanley has been accused of fighting with police. In 2011, University of Pittsburgh police arrested him for resisting arrest, disorderly conduct, public intoxication and simple assault after a fight with another man, university spokesman Joe Miksch said.

Officers alleged that Mr. Stanley refused commands, continued to fight and struck an officer in the face, Mr. Miksch said. All but one of the charges were withdrawn in Magisterial District Court, and Mr. Stanley later pleaded guilty to a single count of disorderly conduct. The court records detailing why the charges were withdrawn were unavailable Monday.

Video of police arresting suspect outside South Side bar

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com, @ShellyBradbury. Staff writer Adam Smeltz contributed.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.