The firm behind the controversial Penn Plaza redevelopment in East Liberty is taking aim at the city for the loss of Whole Foods Market, which pulled out of the project last week.
In a counterclaim to a lawsuit filed by the city in February, Pennley Park South charged that it had suffered more than $10 million in damages associated with the potential loss of the Whole Foods lease.
But the city fired back on Monday that the developer has no one to blame but itself for the decision.
“The lawsuit is more nonsense and a very sad and desperate attempt to rewrite history and make up for their failed development strategy,” said Kevin Acklin, chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto.
In its counterclaim, Pennley Park charged that the city filed the lawsuit, which accused the developer of engaging in demolition activity at the site and failing to provide proper heat for residents, in violation of a memorandum of understanding reached in 2015 even though its own building inspectors were unable to find any code violations.
The counterclaim maintained that the city filed the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court complaint “with actual malice and with the intent to disparage” Pennley Park and to block its redevelopment or to extract additional concessions.
Read More
“The city either negligently failed to investigate the validity of its claims, or alternatively, willfully turned a blind eye to the facts in order to obtain political advantage in the media,” the counterclaim stated.
The counterclaim now leaves the two sides pointing fingers at each other as to who is violating the memorandum of understanding, which was agreed to in September 2015 after Pennley Park began sending notices to tenants advising them to move within 90 days. That prompted intervention by the city, leading to the negotiation of later move-out dates and moving allowances for residents.
Pennley Park filed its counterclaim late Friday, a day after Whole Foods announced that it was suspending its involvement in the project, at least for now, because of concerns raised by the community and Mr. Peduto.
The grocer, which was set to build a 50,000-square-foot store at the site of the former Penn Plaza apartment complex, was going to anchor East Liberty Marketplace, which also is slated to include 200 apartments, 12,000 square feet of offices, and 582 parking spaces in the first phase.
Although Whole Foods hasn’t closed the door on potentially building on the site, the grocer has stressed that it would be up to Pennley Park to work with the city and the community to resolve the issues that have hampered the project for more than a year.
While the city, in its lawsuit, accused developer LG Realty Advisors and affiliate Pennley Park of violating the memorandum of understanding, Pennley Park charged in the counterclaim that the city is the one in violation.
To that end, it accused the city of failing to cooperate in its efforts to get its amended preliminary land development plan approved by the planning commission, which rejected the proposal.
The counterclaim also charged that the city has failed to act to transfer Enright Parklet at the development site to the Urban Redevelopment Authority and ultimately to Pennley Park, and that it failed to act to eliminate or vacate a speed lane, as required by the memorandum.
“What we’re saying is that the city’s failure to deliver on its promises placed the development in peril and as a result of that, we’ve suffered significant damages,” attorney Jonathan Kamin said. “But nevertheless, we’re proceeding forward with the development and want to be made whole by the city.”
Besides the damages related to the Whole Foods decision, Pennley Park stated it had spent more than $250,000 in relocation payments and assistance to Penn Plaza residents; more than $600,000 in maintenance, utility and operating costs on two apartment buildings based on the promises in the memorandum; and more than $725,000 in architectural, engineering and professional fees in relying on those promises.
Pennley Park also accused the city of defamation and slander for claiming in its lawsuit that the developer was engaged in “demolition activity” in the remaining apartment building at the site when it was not.
It is asking a judge to award compensatory, special and punitive damages.
But Mr. Acklin said Pennley Park is at fault, not the city.
“The city cooperated in good faith at all times to respect the residents of Penn Plaza and provide for an open and transparent path for the developer to pursue a community-driven development,” he said. “Ultimately, the developer failed to satisfy the conditions for zoning and planning approvals, and unfortunately have nobody to blame but themselves.”
Mr. Acklin said the memoradum of understanding in some cases was superseded by conditions placed on the development as part of a zoning change approved by council last year. For example, council required that the park remain in the city’s hands, he said.
In answering the city lawsuit’s claims, Pennley Park also charged that it refused to honor a city request to sign a lease with a “known drug dealer so that the drug dealer would be able to obtain relocation assistance and housing vouchers under the applicable federal programs.”
Mr. Acklin disputed that, saying the city has “no knowledge of any such drug dealing allegations.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.