There’s a lot to like about living in Pittsburgh. And that is coming straight from the experts.
Livability.com, a website that annually evaluates cities with populations between 20,000 and 350,000, has placed Pittsburgh in the Top 100 Best Places to Live for 2017. To be exact, we come in at No. 19, finishing in a statistical tie with Arlington, Va.
“Our website showcases small to mid-size cities and looks at why these places are great places to live, and why people should invest in these places and move to these places,” Livability spokeswoman Becky Henson said Monday. “We look at how people enjoy a different quality of life outside of major metro areas.”
This is the fourth time Livability and its partners — researchers at The Initiative for Creativity and Innovation in Cities at New York University’s Schools of Professional Studies — have produced the rankings, painstakingly grading more than 2,100 cities on 40 different data points. The eight categories they look at are economics, housing, amenities, infrastructure, demographics, social and civic capital, education and health care.
Pittsburgh’s strength was in health care, where the city scored a 74 out of 100 points. The weak spot was demographics, which scored only 43.
Ms. Henson said the grades are fairly strict. In four years, she said, she could not recall any city scoring a 90 or above in any category.
Pittsburgh was particularly recognized for its arts, museums, food, drink and sports teams. Shout-outs went to the Warhol Museum, the National Aviary, the Cathedral of Learning, the Benedum Center and Rivers Casino.
The city atop the list — for the second year in a row — is Rochester, Minn. It is followed by Iowa City, Iowa, and Ann Arbor, Mich.
One of the common denominators of the cities on the list is their smaller populations. With a population of 305,928, Pittsburgh is the largest city in the top 100. If you look at the top 50 cities, only No. 8 Madison, Wis. (243,122), No. 18 Arlington, Va. (223,945), No. 38 Chesapeake, Va. (230,601) and No. 40 St. Paul, Minn. (295,043) have more than 200,000 people.
But Ms. Henson said the surveys are not skewed to reflect a “smaller is better” slant.
“There are some data points, however, that favor small cities,” she said. “Culture or social-civic or housing affordability might reflect a bias toward smaller towns.”
One curiosity about the annual rankings is how some cities fluctuate and others are fairly stable. Rochester, Minn., and Palo Alto, Calif., have been in the top seven all four years. Pittsburgh, on the other hand, was No. 80 in 2014, then fell out of the top 100 the next two years before rebounding all the way to No. 19 this year.
Ms. Henson said the rankings fluctuate because of shifting criteria.
“Our data scientists are always looking for new research to bring into the rankings and their algorithms,” she said. “They crunched the numbers multiple times to made sure the numbers were correct, especially this year because Rochester was No. 1 again and we wanted to be sure of that. But it isn’t anything that a city does or doesn’t do.”
Matt Carmichael, a contributing editor and former editor-in-chief of Livability, said the tweaks in methodology reflect all sorts of factors. For example, he said, when California experienced a drought, water availability came into play. The company also has created a new way to measure the availability of quality, high-income jobs.
Livability produces a number of other rankings during the year, including the best places for starting a business or cities where free-lancers can thrive. But what the cities do with the rankings is up to them.
“We’re happy that Pittsburgh is in the top 20 in livability,” Ms. Henson said. “There’s some bragging rights that go with that.”
Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.