The man on Pennsylvania’s death row for killing three Pittsburgh police officers is asking a Common Pleas Court judge to not only dismiss the charges against him but also bar any retrial based on double jeopardy claims.
In a 115-page petition for post-conviction relief that he authored himself, Richard A. Poplawski, 30, alleges a variety of errors he said were made during his June 2011 trial, including multiple instances of ineffective assistance of counsel, as well as prosecutorial misconduct.
The brief, which is written with a certain literary prose, uses extensive legal citations. In it, Poplawski, who received notice of execution slated for March 3, notes that the deadline for him to file a challenge against his final conviction is not until Oct. 3 — seven months after he is scheduled to die.
“A March execution date sets a ‘deadline’ in quite the literal sense,” he wrote.
He alleges that the “looming execution” has placed him “in a state of extreme mental disturbance and duress at the very time when the petitioner is most in need of his mental and emotional equanimity and must call upon his whole range of intellectual faculties in order to prepare a petition for post-conviction relief [by himself.]”
But the dramatic nature of his words are belied by the fact that the March execution date is a formality. Poplawski still has multiple avenues available to him for appeal.
He is scheduled to have a hearing on Thursday before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning to discuss the possible appointment of counsel as his appeals continue. He previously has been represented by the public defender’s office.

In his petition, Poplawski alleges ineffective assistance of counsel, saying that his trial attorneys, Lisa Middleman and Lisa Phillips, as well as William Brennan during the penalty phase of the case, failed to properly object when then-Deputy District Attorney Mark V. Tranquilli made improper comments to the jury, or admitted evidence Poplawski feels was prejudicial.
Poplawski, quoting extensively from the trial transcript, said his attorneys either did not object, or did not object in a timely manner, when Mr. Tranquilli repeatedly referred to Poplawski as a “dog,” “bum,” “coward,” racist and other demeaning terms throughout the trial.
The petition also alleges that the defense should have objected specifically to evidence presented about Poplawski having visited white nationalist websites and when Mr. Tranquilli referred to the three fallen officers, Paul J. Sciullo II, Stephen J. Mayhle and Eric G. Kelly as “heroes.”
“The appellation ‘hero’ bestowed upon the decedents a prestige that diverted the inquiry into the realm of raw sentiment and necessarily prejudiced the accused,” Poplawski wrote. “A jury naturally would be inclined to perceive a person charged with taking a ‘hero’s’ life with profound hostility.”
Poplawski also alleges that the prosecution presented too much victim-impact evidence, saying that it was cumulative and redundant, highly inflammatory and irrelevant, including showing photographs and videos of the officers’ memorial service. That issue was mentioned by former State Supreme Court Chief Justice Ronald Castille at oral argument in 2014, who noted that the evidence was inappropriate and could build in a new trial for Poplawski. However, in its December 2015 opinion, the court wrote that Poplawski did not object to the evidence at trial, and therefore the issue was waived.
In his petition, Poplawski also asks that the entirety of the Allegheny County Common Pleas bench recuse itself from hearing his appeal because Mr. Tranquilli, who at the time of the trial was the head of the district attorney’s homicide unit, is now a judge sitting in the family division.
“The bulk of this petition regards prosecutorial overreaching on the part of the commonwealth represented by Judge Tranquilli. Adjudicating these claims necessarily will require the court to pass judgment on Judge Tranquilli’s egregious conduct,” Poplawski wrote. “The court is in the position to find that a fellow Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge intentionally deprived a capital defendant of a fair trial in a highly sensational and widely publicized case.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.