An ice rink is “still on the table” but that won’t be the only idea the city will consider for the redevelopment of the Hunt Armory in Shadyside.

Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority board members authorized a new round of proposals for the conversion of the historic East End site Thursday but made it clear that any plan brought before them must be financially viable.

Their decision comes more than six months after a proposal to redevelop the building into an Olympic-size ice rink fell apart when the developer was unable to secure the necessary financing for the project.

Kevin Acklin, URA board chairman and chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto, said the city is still hoping that some type of recreational use “stays in the mix” for the redevelopment of the building but added that “we don’t want to just limit it to a single use.”

Advertise with us

While the new request for proposals won’t restrict potential developers, it will caution them that the community had voiced opposition to a residential project in the last go around, URA executive director Robert Rubinstein said. Such a proposal could face an uphill battle, he noted.

Bowing to community wishes, the URA board selected Toronto-based Cadan Inc. and Kratsa Properties in December 2015 to convert the Emerson Street property into a family-friendly ice-skating facility with three rinks, a cafe, and a suspended walking and running track. Among other amenities, there also would have been 164 underground parking spaces.

But in July, Gary Maister of Cadan Inc. notified the city that the firm was withdrawing from the project “due to lenders’ reluctance to finance ice rinks in light of recent rink closures in the region, and the sports medicine groups we have been in discussions with deciding not to consummate leases.”

The URA can’t repeat the same mistake this time, regardless of community pressure, said board member Jim Ferlo, a former city councilman and state senator.

“I don’t want to see an RFP re-issued that does not deal with the harsh reality that it has to be economically feasible,” he said, a position seconded by fellow board member Cheryl Hall-Russell.

Advertise with us
The arched steel framed ceiling of the interior of the Hunt Armory. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

But Mr. Acklin said the city also must be mindful of neighborhood sentiments. It is planning another round of public hearings as part of the latest attempt to redevelop the site.

“This is something they’ve made very clear, that there was a call for a recreational facility,” he said.

In fact, the city itself may seek to engage a co-investor and respond to the request for proposals with a plan for some type of public use, he added.

Asked if the Pittsburgh Penguins, who have been advising the city on the feasibility of the East End project, could be that partner, Mr. Acklin responded, “That’s a possibility.”

While the Penguins, who operate the PPG Paints Arena in Uptown and the UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex in Cranberry, back a rink in the city and have offered to support the administration’s efforts, it is unlikely they would be investors.

Advertise with us

However, they could help the city in putting together a deal and possibly help them find capital. They also have expressed an interest in potentially managing a city ice rink.

The team declined comment Thursday.

While the URA now owns the building, any sale would require the approval of the state, the previous owner. The commonwealth also would get 80 percent of the sale proceeds, Mr. Acklin said.

Under its agreement with the state, the URA must have the armory sold by July 15. But Mr Acklin said the state has expressed a willingness to extend that if the URA is in good faith negotiations with a developer toward reaching a deal.

“We want to move this development,” he said. “Right now it’s an empty building.”

Advertise with us

Also Thursday, the URA board finally hired Mr. Rubinstein as the authority’s full-fledged executive director, with salary and length of term still to be negotiated.

The decision won a round of applause from URA staff members and others gathered for the meeting. Mr. Rubinstein has been serving as acting executive director since March 30, 2012. The arrangement came under fire last month from city controller Michael Lamb, who urged the board to promptly address it.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.