Bill Peduto turned to a consummate insider to head the city’s police force, about 2½ years after bringing in an outsider.

Scott Schubert, chosen by the mayor as permanent chief Friday, is the son of a police officer who has spent 24 years rising through the ranks.

His predecessor, Cameron McLay, was from Madison, Wis. He resigned in November after two years on the job.

Chief Schubert, 50, of Brookline was assistant chief of operations when Mr. Peduto asked him to take over the bureau after Mr. McLay’s resignation. As chief, he will lead a roughly 900-member police force. His appointment is subject to approval by City Council.

Advertise with us

Chief Schubert joined the bureau in 1993 and was a patrolman before becoming a detective in the Mobile Crime Unit, which collects evidence from crime scenes. In 2002, then-Lt. Schubert ran the Squirrel Hill station after its commander, Dominic Costa, was wounded during a standoff with a gunman in Homewood.

A few years later, Chief Schubert was promoted to commander and oversaw the Special Deployment Division, which included the SWAT team and bomb squad. He also oversaw the West End station before becoming an assistant chief about two years ago.

He helped coordinate security during the G-20 Summit in Pittsburgh in 2009 and has worked for many years with the Special Olympics.

Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith, whose district includes the West End, has been a longtime supporter of Chief Schubert.

“He stands with his officers. He stands with the community,” Mrs. Kail-Smith said at the time of his appointment as acting chief. “We don’t have to pit one against the other, and I think he knows that. He knows how to build those relationships and be even more inclusive.”

Advertise with us

Brandi Fisher, president of the Alliance for Police Accountability, said Friday that she is cautiously optimistic about Chief Schubert’s appointment.

There are encouraging signs, she said, such as his willingness to meet with her and publicly express his sympathy over the fatal shooting last weekend by police of a Larimer homeowner.

“So far he’s a great guy, he’s open to meeting, he listens very well, he’s very accessible,” Ms. Fisher said.

After the Larimer shooting — during which officers killed Christopher Mark Thompkins, who reportedly opened fire from inside his house at a suspected burglar just as police arrived on the scene — “We were able to have a very decent dialogue where he listened and also implemented some of my suggestions,” she said.

Those suggestions, she said, including making sure “that when we have these type of situations and we feel sorry ... that we’re conveying that to the community.”

Advertise with us

“A horrible chain of events unfolded on Finley Street in Larimer this past Sunday,” Chief Schubert said in a statement this week. “It’s difficult to find the words to describe the amount of empathy that I have for both the family of Christopher Thompkins and the two officers who were involved in the shooting.”

But Ms. Fisher also said she will wait and see whether Chief Schubert continues to implement reforms and foster improvements in relationships between the police bureau and the community, echoing the views of leaders from various community groups.

“We do hope that he will continue to follow through on the initiatives that Chief McLay started,” said Darlene Figgs, co-chair of the Pittsburgh Interfaith Impact Network.

Ms. Fisher also expressed concerns about how police handled protests following the presidential election. Police used smoke to disperse a crowd that had been blocking traffic in Shadyside, and an argument ensued between the police and protesters.

The police union president said Mr. Peduto pulled up and began berating the incident commander in front of his subordinates, referring to the fact that Mr. McLay had just left town and already the police bureau’s approach had changed under Chief Schubert, who was serving in an acting capacity.

Advertise with us

“What I am concerned about is the internal culture being reshaped and Chief Schubert being able to do that,” Ms. Fisher said. “It seems as though officers felt they could act in a different way under this new leadership.”

Ms. Fisher also questioned why Mr. Peduto did not undertake an extensive search involving external candidates for the top police job as he had done with Mr. McLay.

Peduto spokesman Timothy McNulty said that on the day of Chief McLay’s resignation, the mayor said “that Acting Chief Schubert had 90 days to prove himself, and he did so with flying colors. From holding community meetings citywide, to his handling of demanding police matters the past three months, he has more than proven himself to be the city’s next police chief.”

Mr. McNulty added that Talent City, the organization that did the city’s national searches in 2014, “rated Schubert as the best candidate for the position.”

At the time, though, Mr. Peduto wanted a chief who came from outside Pittsburgh following the conviction and imprisonment of former Chief Nate Harper. “In the meantime,” Mr. McNulty said, “Schubert has basically had two years of on-the-job training to take on this role, for which he is eminently qualified.”

Advertise with us

If anything characterizes old relationships it is Chief Schubert. Although some see that as a potential liability, others, such as the mayor, clearly view it as an asset.

“I think it’ll benefit him because he’s going to know personnel better. He’s going to know who the workers are and who some of the slackers are,” said Allegheny County Sheriff William Mullen, a former city police deputy chief who worked with Chief Schubert. “I think he has a good understanding of the relationships that must be started and maintained with the community in order to have a better police department and a better community.”

Officer Robert Swartzwelder, president of the Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 1, values his long-standing relationship with the chief. He was Chief Schubert’s field training officer decades ago when both were members of the Coraopolis Police Department.

“It’s extremely positive because we’ve known each other over 20 years, and those long-term relationships are hard to replace,” Officer Swartzwelder said. “He has a very difficult role, and I’m sure we’ll agree on some things and there are some things that we won’t agree on. Only time will tell.”

As for searching for another outsider, Officer Swartzwelder was no fan of that approach. The union and Mr. McLay were often at odds, and before the former chief left the FOP took a symbolic vote of no confidence in him. “The city of Pittsburgh tried the outside approach once. It’s probably smart that they tried somebody that elevated through the ranks and was born and raised in the city of Pittsburgh this time around.”

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1962. Staff writers Andrew Goldstein, Liz Navratil, Adam Smeltz and Marianne Mizera contributed.