The Pennsylvania Department of Human Services is investigating a possible suicide attempt Oct. 28 at the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center that occurred about a month after the state agency, following a series of incidents, gave the facility a second warning that it must come into compliance.
DHS Secretary Ted Dallas called the incident “concerning” but stressed, “We want to withhold judgment until we get all the facts together and thoroughly investigate.”
Allegheny County officials said an employee was fired in connection with the incident, but would provide no further details.
DHS in December took away Shuman’s full license and issued a provisional license for a series of incidents at the center in Lincoln-Lemington that houses juvenile offenders. If a facility is handed a provisional license, it means it’s not in compliance with DHS and must create a plan of correction. A facility can be closed if it doesn’t meet state guidelines after four consecutive provisional licenses.
DHS officials on Sept. 30 issued a second provisional license through March 2017, a decision “significantly” influenced by an incident in May, during which a resident’s ear was nearly severed after a pair of employees threw him on a metal bed, Mr. Dallas said. Those employees were fired, according to the county.
County officials wouldn’t provide details about the incident, but according to a DHS report, a resident and a staff member were fighting over a bin in the resident’s bedroom shortly after 8:30 p.m. on May 23. The employee pushed the youth by the neck against the wall. Another staff member threw the resident on the floor, then lay on top of the resident for 15 seconds. The youth was then dragged into the bedroom, and the staffer who lay on the child and another staffer “threw [the child] against the metal bed,” according to interviews in the report.
The facility’s injury report indicates that the resident had a large cut to the ear, which was “nearly severed off” and required about 30 stitches.
At the time of the incident, Shuman was already operating under a provisional license that was issued in December 2015. The provisional license was issued following several other incidents, including one in which a youth care worker propositioned a teen resident for sex. The staff member was subsequently fired.
Years of problems at Shuman came to a head in April 2013 when DHS said reforms enacted after a Shuman worker slammed a 16-year-old into a door frame were inadequate. County Manager William McKain issued a report that criticized the leadership of the facility and recommended broad changes, which he then started implementing. In July of that year, the county fired Shuman director William T. Simmons, who later sued for racial discrimination.
Shuman is licensed to hold up to 120 residents, but its current population is roughly 43, with an average stay between 10 and 12 days, officials said.
Mr. Dallas and some members of the county’s juvenile detention advisory board said Shuman director Earl Hill and his team have taken the state’s appraisals seriously.
“They seemed to be very self-critical in their analysis,” said Brad Korinski, chief legal counsel for the Allegheny County Controller’s office, who represents Controller Chelsa Wagner on the board.
“They are continuing to make improvements, they are continuing to take things seriously,” said board chair Maria Silva, who is the chief program officer at Allegheny Family Network. “They don’t push them under the carpet.”
Mr. Hill declined to talk about the incident involving the youth whose ear was nearly severed, but he said that safety and security at the facility are “paramount” for children and staff and that the administration is working hard to comply with the state’s expectations.
“People really need to know that I’m not making excuses,” he said. “We’re not there yet, where we need to be, but we’re certainly on our way.”
County spokeswoman Amie Downs said County Executive Rich Fitzgerald would defer comment to Mr. Hill since he handles the day-to-day operations.
In interviews, Mr. Hill and Shuman’s deputy director of operations, Rich Gordon, said a “culture change” that includes a more “therapeutic” approach emphasizing dignity and respect is underway. They said they’re trying to strengthen training to focus more on de-escalation techniques and are looking to contract with an organization to bring in a “sanctuary model” therapy and management style that centers on a compassionate, consistent response based on the belief that emotional behavior is likely tied to trauma the children have experienced.
“We’re trying to move in the direction of a kinder, gentler detention center,” Mr. Gordon said.
Mr. Dallas said, “The biggest issue is making sure the folks there get the training they need.”
Among other incidents at Shuman that were noted by DHS:
• In February, a staff member grabbed a resident by the back of the shirt collar, which left red marks on the back of the youth’s neck.
• In March, a staff member grabbed a resident by the neck, threw the resident on the floor and dragged the resident for 15 seconds, leaving the youth’s neck red and tender and with two small fingernail marks. The staff member was fired.
• In April, a resident went into the staff office and was pushed out of the office by an employee. The employee went into the resident’s bedroom and headbutted him, causing him to hit his head on a wall and lose consciousness for 10 to 15 minutes. The employee left and locked the door, and the youth was unconscious, alone in his room, until a nurse came in about eight minutes later.
• Also in April, an employee kicked out a chair out from under a resident as the resident was trying to sit down, then put the youth in seclusion for “failure to follow staffs’ directives.”
• And in June, a resident leaving the shower told a staff member entering the unit not to come in. The staff member told DHS he or she “could not [be concerned] with [the resident’s] rude demand because of his/her reason for being there” and video footage captured the resident only partially dressed. The resident reported having flashbacks and nightmares to previous sexual abuse. The incident, which drew police to the facility, wasn’t initially reported to DHS.
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.