Monte Blair sued Pittsburgh police two years ago for shooting him four times in his SUV, but a federal judge has thrown out his complaint.
U.S. District Judge Mark Kearney on Friday granted the city's request for summary judgment, saying the police were justified in shooting because Blair drove directly at officers Chris Kertis and Andrew Baker and then opened fire on them.
Blair, 43, of Wilmerding, is serving a prison term from the Sept. 9, 2012, incident in Homewood.
The two officers were responding to shots fired at 2 a.m. and said they saw muzzle flashes coming from a dark-colored SUV. They gave chase in their police van but lost sight of the vehicle. As they turned down an alley, they said Blair's SUV sped towards their van. Blair fired a gun at them as he drove past. The officers returned fire as Blair sped past and away from them and hit him four times in the arm.
Blair said in his suit that the officers used excessive force and that the city didn't train them properly. He also accused the city of malicious prosecution in arresting him for both shootings.
The judge ruled that the two officers are entitled to qualified immunity because they were trying to protect themselves and the public.
"Officers Kertis and Baker shot at Blair because they reasonably believed he posed a threat of harm to them by driving at them at a high rate of speed after having just seen Blair shoot at a private citizen," Judge Kearney said.
He also ruled that police had probable cause to arrest Blair and dismissed his claim that the city didn't train the officers well.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.