The former University of Pittsburgh researcher found guilty of first-degree murder for killing his wife with cyanide in 2013 has lost his initial appeal.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning wrote in a 45-page opinion that Robert Ferrante’s conviction was driven by expert testimony about the cause of death, further supported by circumstantial evidence of marital discord and Google searches on how a medical examiner can detect the presence of cyanide.
“It was for the jury to decide if they accepted the opinion of the commonwealth witnesses on the issue of causation or if the testimony of the defendant’s witnesses were sufficient to raise a reasonable doubt,” Judge Manning wrote. “By their verdict, the jury made it clear that they credited the testimony of the commonwealth’s witness.”
Ferrante’s appellate attorney, Chris Eyster, said they will appeal.
“We respect Judge Manning, but we disagree with his opinion. We will challenge every aspect of the opinion,” Mr. Eyster said. “We believe Ferrante will get a new trial and more reliable scientific evidence will be presented in the courtroom than in the first trial.”
Ferrante, 67, is serving life in prison for poisoning his wife, Autumn Klein, in their home April 17, 2013.
Read More
Prosecutors said that when Dr. Klein returned home from work about 11 p.m. that evening, Ferrante gave her a drink laced with cyanide. She collapsed in their kitchen. Ferrante called 911, and his wife was rushed to UPMC Presbyterian, where she worked as a neurologist.
She survived for more than two days, although she was brain-dead.
A jury convicted Ferrante of first-degree murder in November 2014, and he was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole. He is currently at the State Correctional Institution at Houtzdale.
Mr. Eyster filed an appeal with Judge Manning, who presided over the trial.
The appeal challenged search warrants in the case, as well as the weight and sufficiency of the evidence. Ferrante also contended that the prosecution failed to provide exculpatory information to his defense that a subsidiary of the lab that obtained the fatal cyanide test result had previously pleaded guilty in criminal court of continuing to use a test for another substance that officials knew provided inaccurate results. It paid a $40 million fine.
In the opinion filed last week, Judge Manning denied all of the defense claims, writing that the alleged facts in the search warrants were “more than sufficient to establish probable cause.”
As to the claims involving the lab subsidiary — the Nichols Institute — the court called them “specious.”
“Quest Diagnostics did not plead guilty to a crime,” Judge Manning wrote. “A subsidiary, Nichols Diagnostic, did. More importantly, Quest Diagnostics did not testify in this trial.”
Instead, the court continued, four employees did.
“None of these witnesses could have been impeached with evidence that a subsidiary of the corporation they worked for was convicted in an unrelated criminal matter.”
Judge Manning also dismissed Ferrante’s arguments about the weight and sufficiency of the evidence, finding that it is “abundantly clear that the evidence in this case was sufficient to sustain the jury’s verdict.”
In addition to expert testimony, the court cited significant circumstantial evidence in the case.
That included emails between the victim and defendant suggesting marital problems, as well as Ferrante’s Google searches surrounding cyanide poisoning before and after Dr. Klein’s collapse.
“Searches on the computer for information as to how difficult it is for a medical examiner to detect the presence of cyanide is certainly suspicious of a guilty mind,” Judge Manning wrote.
Once the jury believed Dr. Klein died from cyanide poisoning, the circumstantial evidence, the court said, was sufficient to prove Ferrante killed her.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.