Pittsburgh officials should have given a local businessman a chance to appeal before they closed his South Side establishment this month, an attorney for the business argued in court Monday.

The city shut down Mother Fletcher’s, 2200 E. Carson St., less than four hours after its 9 p.m. debut Sept. 3, alleging the operation ran afoul of its occupancy permit. The permit allows a restaurant, which is how business owner Brandon Firman of Churchill and his attorneys classify the alcohol-free enterprise.

But Mother Fletcher’s amounts to an underage dance club, a primary use not allowed under the formal approvals received by Mr. Firman’s company, city officials testified before U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer. Attorneys for the company filed a federal lawsuit last week asserting that the city violated its own procedures and Mr. Firman’s constitutional right to due process.

“The city took a ‘ready, shoot, aim’ approach, acted as judge and jury,” said Christopher Cahillane, an attorney representing Mr. Firman. Under city rules, he said, enforcement officials should have referred their concerns to a municipal zoning board and let Mother Fletcher’s continue doing business in the meantime.

Advertise with us

Mr. Firman, on the witness stand, maintained that a restaurant classification suits his youth-oriented establishment, which he said includes dancing, strobe lighting and a DJ booth in the former Margaritaville. He acknowledged that potato chips, pretzels and Pop-Tarts were the only foods available at the Sept. 3 opening but said he plans to develop a more robust menu in time.

Michael Kennedy, an assistant city solicitor, said the city can order immediate closures in emergency situations.

“The mere serving of some potato chips does not transform an establishment from a dance club to a restaurant,” Mr. Kennedy said.

Mr. Kennedy pointed in part to marketing that promises “the biggest and most out-of-control Under-21 party on this side of the United States!” — but no mention of food service. One promotion encouraged young women to wear bikinis.

That concerned Maura Kennedy, the director of the city Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections. The prospect of 15-year-olds in swimsuits departing Mother Fletcher’s at 1 a.m. bothered her, she said, in a neighborhood where so many intoxicated people roam.

Advertise with us

City officials have said Mr. Firman’s company could reapply to do business as an underage dance club. Oral arguments before Judge Fischer are set to continue at 9:30 a.m. today at the federal courthouse, Downtown.

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.

Correction (Sept. 13, 2:36 p.m.): This story incorrectly identified the name of the business formerly located at the Mother Fletcher’s site. The correct business is Margaritaville.