A man who was shot and paralyzed by police won a legal battle Monday but lost several others.

A judge said Leon Ford, 23, can continue with his civil rights suit against the officer who shot him and another who he said tried to drag him out of his car during a traffic stop four years ago.

But the judge threw out claims against a third officer and the city of Pittsburgh.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Maureen Kelly said a jury will have to decide whether Officer David Derbish violated Mr. Ford’s rights when he shot him five times.

Advertise with us

Officer Derbish had asked for summary judgment on Mr. Ford’s claim of excessive force, but the judge denied his motion because she said the facts are disputed as to whether the force was “reasonable.”

Among those disputed facts are whether Mr. Ford posed a threat, whether there was a bulge in his sweatpants that officers thought was a weapon, why Officer Derbish jumped into Mr. Ford’s car in violation of police policy and whether Mr. Ford was trying to get away when his car started rolling forward.

“These disputes should be resolved by a jury, not the court,” the judge said.

She said judgment in Officer Derbish’s favor was “not appropriate because there is evidence which, if believed, could contradict” officer testimony that he acted appropriately.

Judge Kelly also said an assault and battery count brought by Mr. Ford against Officer Andrew Miller can go forward.

Advertise with us

But she ruled for the city on claims against a third officer, Michael Kosko, and also rejected Mr. Ford’s assertion that the city hadn’t trained or supervised its officers well enough.

Lawyers for the city could not be reached.

Monte Rabner, Mr. Ford’s lawyer, said the decision was a “great day” for his client.

He said four years ago Mr. Ford was unjustly accused of wrongdoing in a criminal case. But the “correct defendants will now be forced to stand trial just as Leon Ford did.”

Officer Derbish shot Mr. Ford during a traffic stop in Highland Park on Nov. 11, 2012.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ford sued the city and the officers involved in 2013.

His suit cited claims of unreasonable search and seizure, false arrest and imprisonment and excessive force, as well as a claim that the city failed to adequately train its officers.

The city had filed motions for summary judgment asking the judge to throw out Mr. Ford’s claims.

The ruling was mixed.

First, she denied the officers’ argument that they are protected by qualified immunity, which shields public officials from being sued for actions related to their official duties, because she said there are too many disputed facts.

Advertise with us

But she sided with officers Kosko and Miller in deciding they did not violate Mr. Ford’s protections against illegal search and seizure when they pulled him over for running a stop sign because his conviction for not stopping was upheld in state court.

She also granted summary judgment for officers Kosko and Miller on Mr. Ford’s claim of “unreasonable seizure” for the shooting because neither man shot him.

In addition, she said officers Derbish and Miller are not entitled to summary judgment on assault and battery counts because the “reasonableness” of the force they used is in dispute.

As for Officer Kosko, she said there is no evidence that he tried to drag Mr. Ford out of the car.

A county jury convicted Mr. Ford of traffic violations in 2014 but acquitted him of aggravated assault in connection with the traffic stop. Jurors deadlocked on the remaining offenses, including reckless endangerment and resisting arrest. The district attorney elected not to retry Mr. Ford.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.