The Diocese of Pittsburgh contends that the U.S. government is making an “extremely aggressive” attempt to get contraceptive coverage to female employees of Catholic Charities even as the diocese continues to battle in court over the Obamacare mandate for such coverage.
The diocese and the feds are in a long-running legal dispute over religious liberty and the Affordable Care Act, which went up to the U.S. Supreme Court before the justices kicked it back down to lower courts earlier this year in hopes of reaching a settlement.
Bishop David Zubik was the lead plaintiff in the case, in which Catholic Charities of Pittsburgh and numerous faith-based charities and schools around the country sought an exemption from having any role in employees getting contraceptives that they object to on grounds of conscience.
But even while the case is pending, “we are aware that the government has made an extremely aggressive interpretation of the court’s order in the Zubik case and is apparently trying to take over — to force our third-party administrators to include the objectionable coverage in our self-insured plans,” the diocese said in a statement. “We think that is an erroneous reading of what the Supreme Court said.”
But others are pleased the government is acting.
“Obviously we’re deeply concerned about these employees and their ability to get coverage for contraceptives,” said Brigitte Amiri, senior staff attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union’s Reproductive Freedom Project, which filed a brief supporting government policy in the recent Supreme Court case.
The Affordable Care Act generally requires free contraceptive coverage to women as a preventive care measure. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services exempts churches and other strictly religious organizations from that mandate. It also allows faith-based schools and charities to opt out — but only if those agencies submit written notice of their objection. In such cases, the insurance companies would provide coverage to the women for free. But Bishop Zubik and the other plaintiffs argued that this provision, which can be enforced with large fines, forces the agencies to play a role in triggering an outcome they object to.
When the U.S. Supreme Court sent the matter back to lower courts, it also authorized the feds in the meantime to begin the process of getting contraceptive services for female employees of Catholic Charities and the other objecting agencies.
The court said that the lawsuits filed by the agencies — challenging the requirement that they serve notice of their objections — could be interpreted as being, in fact, notice of their objections. “Through this litigation, (the agencies) have made the government aware” of their desire to opt out, the court said.
The U.S. government said in a court filing that it will start notifying insurers of these agencies to start providing contraceptives.
Catholic Charities of Pittsburgh is self-insured, with a third-party administrator, or contractor, managing its health care plans. The diocese also contends that the law does not require third-party administrators to comply.
The diocese says its attorneys have been meeting with government lawyers in hopes of resolving the case.
In the meantime, the government posted a formal Request for Information in the Federal Register asking for input on a possible settlement. The diocese and other plaintiffs said in a court brief that it could accept a scenario in which the agencies simply asked an insurer for a health plan that didn’t include contraceptives, without having to notify the government or be threatened with fines, and the insurer then provided the contraceptives separately.
The government defends its current plan but says it could reluctantly consider such a scenario.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.