Prosecutors have asked that the preliminary hearing for two men charged with killing five people and an unborn child in Wilkinsburg in March be moved to the Allegheny County Courthouse.
In a motion for change of venue received by Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning on Monday, the district attorney’s office alleged that Cheron Shelton, 29, and Robert Thomas, 27, are a danger to the community at large, and that there is a “potential for retaliation [that] also puts the defendants’ lives at risk.”
They asked for the hearing, which was originally scheduled for Friday at City Court on First Avenue, to be held instead at the courthouse on Grant Street to ensure better security. The hearing will likely be held on July 29.
Shelton and Thomas are charged with multiple counts of homicide, aggravated assault and conspiracy.
They were charged on Thursday in relation to the March 9 mass shooting at a backyard cookout on Franklin Avenue that killed siblings Jerry Michael Shelton, 35, Brittany Powell, 27, and Chanetta Powell, 25, and their cousins Tina Shelton, 37, and Shada Mahone, 26. Chanetta Powell was eight months pregnant.
Later this week, defense attorney Randall McKinney, who represents Cheron Shelton in the homicide case, as well as a 2013 drug case, expects to file his response to another motion filed by prosecutors.
Read More
Earlier this month, the district attorney’s office alleged that Mr. McKinney has a conflict of interest because he also represents Shelton’s girlfriend, Channel Falls, 30, and her father, Adrien Falls, 53, who are charged with hindering apprehension when police were seeking Shelton in the drug case.
According to the prosecution motion, Mr. McKinney’s representation of all three is “improper.”
Citing the state rules of professional conduct, they wrote, there is a conflict of interest if representing one client will be “directly adverse to another” or if there is a risk that one client’s representation will be limited “by the lawyer’s responsibilities to another client.”
The DA’s office alleges an “actual or serious conflict of interest because they each have antagonistic defenses.”
“McKinney’s responsibilities to Channel and Adrien Falls will be materially limited by his responsibilities to Cheron Shelton,” the motion said.
Further, Mr. McKinney representing both daughter and father also creates a conflict, the prosecution wrote, because their defenses will be antagonistic as well.
The motion also notes that Shelton has a pending simple assault case in which Channel Falls is listed as the victim, although Mr. McKinney is not representing Shelton in that case.
The disqualification motion will be handled by the trial judge assigned to the cases.
Mr. McKinney expects to file his written response this week but said Monday he disagrees with the prosecution’s assessment.
“Nothing in the police reports is indicative of any actual conflict. There has to be an actual, articulable conflict on the record,” Mr. McKinney said.
Although the DA’s motion does not spell it out, a timeline of events following the Wilkinsburg shooting might. According to investigators, Shelton was in touch with Channel Falls in the hours after the attack, including phone calls at 2:59 a.m. and another at 3:17 a.m. In addition, police said Ms. Falls drove Shelton back to his mother’s home on Nolan Court that morning at 3:57 a.m.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.