The University of Notre Dame has long been displaying valuable figurines dating to the early-American Olmec empire that were stolen two decades ago from a retired Squirrel Hill banker and art collector, according to a lawsuit.

Scott Leff, the son of the late Jay Leff of Squirrel Hill, who had been president of Fayette Bank and Trust in Uniontown, blames his father’s ex-wife, saying she pilfered the collection in 1996 after the senior Leff filed for divorce.

Scott Leff says Notre Dame’s Snite Museum of Art has several hundred of his father’s figurines, worth some $575,000, and he wants them back.

Scott and his wife, Marilyn McDaniel, filed suit in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas last month and the case was transferred this week to federal court.

Advertise with us

Mr. Leff said he learned in 2015 that Notre Dame bought his father’s collection a decade earlier from a New Mexico dealer who, according to the suit, bought it from Jay Leff’s ex-wife.

The university said in correspondence with Scott Leff and his lawyer that Mr. Leff has no proof of ownership and did nothing to get the art back for 20 years.

Scott Leff’s lawyer didn’t return messages. Dennis Brown, a university spokesman, said the school acquired the figurines in good faith from a reputable seller and is “confident in its ownership of full rightful title” to them.

Jay Leff, a well-known collector whose pieces have been part of several exhibits and who once served as the second chairman of the Pennsylvania State Council on the Arts, died of a heart attack in 2000 at age 75.

Five years earlier, he filed for divorce from his second wife. After that, according to the lawsuit, she stole part of his collection and “dispersed it.” Scott Leff, who had power of attorney for his father, called Pittsburgh police and said the ex-wife was the suspect because she had keys to two North Craig Street apartments and a self-storage facility where the art was kept.

Advertise with us

Notre Dame acquired the figurines in 2005 from Economos Works of Art in Sante Fe, which received them from the ex-wife in 2001, according to the suit.

“Even if Notre Dame acted innocently, unknowingly and in good faith,” the suit says, “plaintiffs retain sole lawful title to the Leff Figurines and their property rights remain senior to those of Notre Dame.”

The school told Scott Leff’s lawyer that it bought the collection from a legitimate dealer, Economos, and said the Leff family has no evidence beyond the police report of a theft. Notre Dame’s general counsel and a lawyer for Economos also said that it appears no one ever followed up on the police report.

“To our knowledge, the allegations in the police report were never supported with a conviction,” they wrote. “Nor does it appear that your client even filed suit against [the ex-wife] to recover the property back when facts about the ‘theft’ were readily available and the memories of those involved were fresh.”

The lawyers said they don’t believe that a “true owner of this valuable art would do nothing for 20 years about the theft of art allegedly worth $1/​2 million.”