A federal court jury on Tuesday rejected the claims of a Pittsburgh police officer who said the city and former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl retaliated against her for complaining about excess Downtown parking spaces allocated to valet service owner Robert Gigliotti, a friend of the mayor’s.

After deliberating about an hour following a weeklong trial, the eight-person jury found in favor of the city and Mr. Ravenstahl and against Officer Tonya Ford.

She had sued in 2014, saying the city violated her First Amendment rights and her protections under Pennsylvania’s whistle-blower law when officials placed her on paid leave in 2013.

She returned in April after 38 months off the job.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ravenstahl, now a manager of business and sales for Peoples Natural Gas, said the verdict validates his contention that he did nothing improper when he approved placing her on leave while the FBI investigated former Chief Nate Harper and the police department.

He said he made the decision because the FBI had information that Officer Ford was close to Harper and may have been involved in the financial fraud that sent him to prison. She was cleared, but Mr. Ravenstahl said he had to make a choice based on what he knew at the time.

“The verdict confirmed what I knew all along,” he said. “It’s a decision that I knew to be true.”

Mike Kennedy, the assistant city solicitor who tried the case, said the verdict was what he expected. In his closing argument on Monday, he told the jury that Officer Ford was unable to provide any evidence that the city retaliated against her because of her complaints about Mr. Gigliotti.

Officer Ford’s lawyer, Sam Cordes, said he and his client were disappointed but conceded that without a paper or email trail to show that Officer Ford complained and was punished for it, the case was difficult to prove. He said the easy employment discrimination cases are the ones that settle.

Advertise with us

“She fought the fight. She’s back at work,” he said. “The jury paid close attention and made a decision, and we respect that.”

Officer Ford said in her suit that she had long complained about parking variances granted to Mr. Gigliotti’s Tri State Valet. She said she was targeted because Mr. Gigliotti was a political supporter of Mr. Ravenstahl and close to Harper.

The city countered that she was placed on leave because of her ties to Harper at a time when he was under investigation by the FBI for stealing public money from a police credit union account.

Mr. Ravenstahl said on the stand and again after the verdict that he approved the decision by Public Safety director Mike Huss out of an “abundance of caution” during the FBI probe of Harper and the police department. Mr. Huss had testified that he had information at the time from the FBI and others that Officer Ford was tied to the account from which Harper stole money, and that he placed her on leave to preserve the integrity of the ongoing investigation.

The FBI had also been looking into Mr. Ravenstahl’s conduct, but he said after the verdict that the investigation was an “extensive fishing expedition” that went nowhere.

Advertise with us

“I did nothing wrong,” he said. “I’ve already moved on with my life.”

The U.S. Attorney’s office would not comment on whether the Ravenstahl inquiry is closed.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.