A Braddock man confessed to a North Fayette detective that he struck Mark Lopata in the head with a hammer and then shot him, according to a Pittsburgh police affidavit supporting the arrest of Robert Hunter.
Pittsburgh police got involved May 27 but could not crack the case until the detective gave an official statement Tuesday.
On May 27, the landlady for Lopata, who lived at 702 Harker St. in the city’s Elliott neighborhood, checked on his well-being after seeing a post on Facebook that he was missing. She and a neighbor found Lopata’s severely decomposed body.
Another neighbor told police that Hunter had been staying with Lopata.
On Sunday, Pittsburgh police learned from an autopsy that Lopata, 35, had been shot and struck in the head.
Two days later, Detective Donald Cokus told Pittsburgh investigators that he had known Hunter for six to eight months and had spoken to him “frequently” by phone, according to the affidavit. The nature of their relationship was not clear.
Read More
“Some of that stuff is confidential, the way I’ve worked with him in the past,” Detective Cokus said Thursday.
Detective Cokus told Pittsburgh police that Hunter had contacted him Saturday and told him he had a dispute with Lopata, hit him over the head with a hammer and then shot Lopata with Lopata’s gun, the affidavit said.
“Hunter was able to provide Cokus with details about the homicide which would only be known to one familiar with the crime scene and the autopsy report,” the affidavit said.
An autopsy the next day verified the story Detective Cokus said Hunter told him.
Hunter, 28, of Braddock was arraigned early Thursday on criminal homicide and other charges.
Detective Cokus would not discuss his interactions with Pittsburgh police regarding his conversation with Hunter other than saying, “If I didn’t provide that, they’d have a much tougher time prosecuting this case.”
His boss, Lt. Michael Hamm, said Detective Cokus turned over the information to Pittsburgh “immediately.”
Pittsburgh police Cmdr. Larry Scirotto said Detective Cokus first contacted Pittsburgh May 28 with Hunter’s story.
But Sonya Toler, a Pittsburgh police spokeswoman, wrote in an email, “The detective gave the information to our investigators for the first time on May 31.”
On that day, Cmdr. Scirotto said, Detective Cokus came to police headquarters for a formal taped statement. The commander did not know why it was not sooner.
“VCU [Violent Crime Unit] investigators were notified of this information on 5/28/16 and received a formal statement on 5/31/16. The delay was not excessive or unreasonable, and all investigative information has to be vetted and formalized to present to the D.A.’s office,” Cmdr. Scirotto said.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.