When Pittsburgh police Officer Tonya Montgomery-Ford began telling her bosses that she believed favors were being done to benefit politically connected local businessman Robert Gigliotti, her chronic complaints were mostly dismissed, she testified Monday.
Instead of addressing her concerns, numerous supervisors told her to “back off,” Officer Montgomery-Ford told an eight-member jury hearing her civil rights case against the city of Pittsburgh and its former mayor, Luke Ravenstahl.
Taking the stand for 90 minutes on the first day of trial before U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti, Officer Montgomery-Ford explained how the parking variances she oversaw were used as political capital within the police bureau and city hall during the Ravenstahl administration. Parking variances give their holders, such as valet companies and construction contractors, the right to park cars at metered spaces without paying.
In 2013, for instance, then-police Chief Nate Harper ordered her to revoke a parking variance for Democratic labor leader Robert Kramm because Mr. Ravenstahl learned that Mr. Kramm was supporting mayoral rival Bill Peduto in the upcoming election, she testified.
“I didn’t think it was fair to be put in the middle of this political process,” Officer Montgomery-Ford said.
Read More
But that’s exactly what happened, according to her attorney Samuel J. Cordes. In February 2013, the officer was suspended with pay for more than three years without explanation and was only recently ordered back to work. Mr. Cordes claims his client was being punished for complaining about Mr. Gigliotti, cooperating with a federal investigation that landed Harper in federal prison on tax and conspiracy charges, and testifying before a federal grand jury.
In 2013, Officer Montgomery-Ford said, she spoke with the FBI, the U.S. Attorney’s office and the IRS about parking variances.
“We sat down and went through all of Mr. Gigliotti’s variances for all the years that he received them,” she testified. “I told them Mr. Gigliotti was a friend and political supporter of Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, and Mr. Gigliotti was given whatever he asked for without the same conditions placed on other valet companies.”
Officer Montgomery-Ford told jurors that Harper, Mr. Ravenstahl, former Assistant Chief George Trosky and the city’s former public safety director Mike Huss (now deputy director) all applied pressure on Mr. Gigliotti’s behalf so he could secure a disproportionate number of parking variances for Tri-State Valet.
Officer Montgomery-Ford said her supervisors would tell her, “He’s a political supporter and good friend of the mayor and Director Huss and just leave him be.” She said she would respond, “This is wrong. He’s breaking the rules that other valet companies are made to follow, and it’s not fair. They would do nothing.”
Mr. Cordes alleged in his opening statement that Mr. Gigliotti “took over Fifth Avenue in the evening,” filling the Downtown corridor with parked cars in spaces that Tri-State was getting for free from the city — and then charging patrons commercial garage rates.
Associate City Solicitor Michael E. Kennedy called the plaintiff’s focus on parking variances a “red herring” and “salacious story about politics.” Officer Montgomery-Ford was suspended, he said, because she was a confidante of Harper’s and the city had to explore whether she was involved in the conspiracy to direct more than $70,000 in city money to secret accounts, some of which was used for Harper’s personal expenses. Mr. Cordes said she was not involved.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.