Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto is seeking an independent review of the promotion process for an officer who today was made a sergeant because he had been subject briefly to a restraining order filed by his ex-wife a decade ago.
Thomas Mignogna, 59, a nine-year veteran, was promoted Thursday morning. But after questions were raised by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette about the officer's background and the vetting process used to determine whether he should be promoted, the mayor said he has ordered police Chief Cameron McLay to seek a review.
“Given the seriousness of domestic violence and my life-long commitment to the cause of protecting its victims, I have instructed Chief McLay to engage with the independent [Pittsburgh Citizen] Police Review Board to assure that city code regarding zero tolerance for domestic violence was fully followed in this case, and to report back to me immediately,” Mr. Peduto said in a statement.
As of Thursday evening, Elizabeth Pittinger, the review board’s executive director, said she had not heard from any city official about a review.
In 2006 the sergeant was accused in a protection-from-abuse petition — which contained unproven allegations — of stalking and controlling his ex-wife. He was never charged, and the petition was withdrawn.
Both the mayor and the chief released statements Thursday evening saying the information about Sgt. Mignogna's past was known by the city during his hiring. Mr. Peduto said it was considered during the promotion process.
Read More
The restraining order against Sgt. Mignogna, who was not a Pittsburgh police officer at the time, took effect March 15, 2006, and led a judge to temporarily bar him from the house of his then-wife, Diane Mignogna, in Pitcairn. Neither could be reached for comment.
Two weeks later, on March 29, 2006, the order was withdrawn at the request of the former Mrs. Mignogna.
In a narrative filed in court, the plaintiff wrote that although the couple was separated and Sgt. Mignogna was living in Maryland, "He returns every week to stalk me. He drives by my house, questions neighbors about what I am doing. Wearing all black was seen outside my door. [Defendant] is a police officer with Metropolitan DC police and knows exactly how far to go with the stalkings. While living with [defendant] he limited my contact with family and friends. He is controlling and displaying erratic behavior making me fearful for the safety of myself and my child."
While Sgt. Mignogna was not charged with any crime, his promotion comes against a backdrop of concerns raised in the past about allowing officers to advance through the ranks despite allegations of domestic issues.
Pittsburgh police policy states that when it comes to promotions, the chief "shall not recommend" to the public safety director an officer with an active protection-from-abuse order or pending criminal case. It also say that "an officer's domestic violence history will be included when considering an officer for promotions and/or assignment to Field Training Officer positions."
The previous uproar stemmed from the simultaneous promotion in June 2007 — four months after Sgt. Mignogna was hired — of three officers who had run-ins with law enforcement over domestic issues. They included a former commander, George Trosky (later made an assistant chief), a former lieutenant, Charles Rodriguez, and Sgt. Eugene Hlavac.
Mr. Trosky, who was promoted to commander from the rank of detective, was arrested in 1997 for breaking his then-wife's nose, but a simple assault charge was dropped after she did not appear in court. Mr. Rodriguez, who was promoted from sergeant, was charged with assaulting his daughter, but the charge was withdrawn. And police were called to the home of Sgt. Hlavac, formerly an officer, for an incident described by the bureau's former deputy chief as a "nonviolent, oral domestic."
Following those promotions, an outcry from women's groups spurred the city to enact legislation that created a domestic abuse policy for the police bureau.
Chief McLay declined to be interviewed today. His statement said: "The matter that you bring up is something that occurred in Sgt. Mignogna's remote [past] and was part of the information the Office of Municipal Investigation[s] collected during the pre-hire process. The temporary order was withdrawn and there were no charges, no arrest and no further court action. With that said, Mignogna has been an exemplary officer since being hired in 2007 and was properly promoted to the rank of sergeant."
Ms. Pittinger said she would be happy to work with Chief McLay to review Sgt. Mignogna’s promotion.
“We’ll see what it yields,” Ms. Pittinger said.
She said part of a review would likely include checking whether any complaints had been filed against the sergeant alleging unbecoming conduct or aggressive, threatening language used toward the public.
Ms. Pittinger noted that because Sgt. Mignogna’s hiring predated the high-profile triple promotions that led to policy changes, “His initial hire technically wouldn’t have been subject to that higher level of scrutiny.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.