The recent vote by the city’s Historic Review Commission to recommend historic designation for the former Albright United Methodist Church in Bloomfield has prompted a lawsuit in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
The Western Pennsylvania Conference of the United Methodist Church filed suit last week against the city, the Friendship Community Group and six individuals.
Conference attorneys warned the commission last month it would fight historic designation. The commission approved the designation March 2. Historic designation is not final until the planning commission and then city council vote on it.
Historic designation protects a building from demolition unless it is a public hazard or the owner can prove hardship.
At issue is whether Albright is a religious building. City ordinance exempts religious buildings from being nominated except by their owners. Anyone can nominate a nonreligious building. Conference attorney David Barton said it is government overreach for the city’s commission to decide that it is not a religious building.
Lindsay Patross, of the Friends of Albright, nominated the 110-year-old Gothic-Romanesque building for historic designation in the fall.
The Albright church, at 486 S. Graham St., stopped being used for regular worship in 2013, but the Rev. George Porter, an appointed pastor, began holding worship services there Dec. 4 and regularly since then, he told the commission March 2.
Brian Bevan, an attorney for a congregation group that wants to save the church, questioned the motive for restarting services just after Ms. Patross nominated the building.
Conference chancellor and attorney Amy Bentz cited the separation of church and state in imploring the commission not to interfere with the conference’s right “to marshal its own assets.”
She said the building would need at least $1.3 million to be usable. Proceeds from its sale would be used “to develop multicultural programming, low-income housing, literacy programs and a feeding ministry,” she said. “None of that can be done with this burdensome building.”
A sales agreement in excess of $1 million is pending. Ross Development, the prospective buyer, has proposed a drive-through retail for the site. The city’s zoning board of adjustment denied a special exception for that use, and that denial also is under appeal.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.