Bruce Kelley Jr. wasn’t moving any farther. At least nine police officers had been following him for several minutes after he fought with two Port Authority officers along the East Busway in Wilkinsburg Sunday afternoon, injuring one with a knife. They deployed pepper spray and Tasers on him multiple times to no avail.
“You can’t hurt me,” he reportedly told the officers. “That doesn’t hurt me.”
It was then, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said, that Port Authority Officer Brian O’Malley announced that he was going to release his police dog, Aren.
“‘You release the dog, I’m killing the [expletive] dog,’ ” Mr. Zappala said Kelley responded.
Officer O’Malley released Aren, and the 5-year-old German shepherd latched on to Kelley’s left arm. Kelley used his right hand to stab the dog in the bottom of its snout, slicing an artery in the tongue, causing it to bleed to death.
Officer O’Malley fired 10 shots at Kelley in response, and another officer fired twice, killing him.
Read More
“Could we have done something short of taking a human life? I feel like we need to have that discussion,” Mr. Zappala said. “This is not about a dog. This discussion is about police training, policies and procedures.”
The top county prosecutor met with the media Thursday afternoon — the same day that Aren was remembered on the North Shore by hundreds of officers who gathered for his memorial service.
Mr. Zappala said he has not yet determined if Kelley’s shooting was justified, but he did say that the officers involved in the incident followed the use of force continuum. After pepper spray and use of a Taser, Mr. Zappala said, releasing a police dog is the last step before deploying deadly force.
“You use the K-9 as a last instance before lethal force becomes appropriate,” he said.
Under Pennsylvania law, deadly force is justified when it is necessary to prevent death or bodily injury or when it is necessary to prevent escape and the person has committed a forcible felony, Mr. Zappala said.
“Obviously, if you come at an officer with a knife, that’s aggravated assault. He’s a definite threat with the knife.” Stabbing a police dog, too, is a forcible felony.
Video from Port Authority cameras at the Hamnett station in Wilkinsburg shows Kelley, who was wearing four layers of clothing, including heavy overalls, walking quickly away from at least nine officers who converged near the busway after the two initial Port Authority officers called for backup. Those two officers had been investigating a report of men drinking in a small park along the busway. Kelley and his father, Bruce Kelley Sr., fought the officers. At some point, Kelley Jr. pulled the 4-inch knife from his jacket and began moving away from the scrum.
Allegheny County police Superintendent Charles Moffatt said on Sunday that the male officer’s hands were sliced by the knife. Mr. Zappala could not confirm that.
The video, taken about a quarter-mile away from where the incident began, shows Kelley holding the knife in his hand as officers surround him. Only one officer had his firearm drawn, the others held pepper spray and Tasers at the ready.
At one point, an officer attempted to disarm Kelley with his baton from his flank, but Kelley saw him and quickly wheeled around, avoiding him. Seconds later, the video followed Kelley as he hopped a chain-link fence, but he and the officers moved out of camera range before the shooting.
It was about 90 seconds from the time the officer attempted to use the baton before Officer O’Malley released the dog.
Mr. Zappala could not say what prompted the officers to release the dog when they did — whether Kelley made an aggressive movement or something else.
But, he said, “you can’t let him go. He’s not rational, it appears. He has a deadly weapon.”
When asked if the officers could have simply tried to wait Kelley out, Mr. Zappala hesitated before saying, “The county’s not done with their investigation.”
Following intense discussion in the community over the use of police dogs and two stabbing deaths of police dogs in two years, Mr. Zappala has requested the police dog policies of police departments across the county.
Police dogs are wearing vests more frequently, said James A. Cortina of the Connecticut Police Work Dog Association Inc., because shootings and stabbings of the dogs appear to be increasing.
Dogs generally cannot wear vests the entire time they are on duty because they are heavy, can restrict movement and cause the dog to overheat, Mr. Cortina said. And vests can’t protect a dog shot or stabbed in the head, as Aren was.
Unleashing a police dog is never the first thing that police officers do, Mr. Cortina said.
“You negotiate first. They do all they can before they send in the dog. Some people, no matter how many warnings, will not stop.”
In the case of Kelley, Mr. Zappala said it is unclear why he would not heed officers’ commands. He noted that the suspect was on probation out of Washington County, and a new arrest could have led to his re-incarceration.
Toxicology results from Kelley’s autopsy are not back yet, Mr. Zappala said.
A funeral service for Kelley will be held at 4 p.m. Monday at Apostolic Christian Temple, 164 W. Wylie Ave., Washington, Pa. He was the son of Kelley Sr. and Johnnie Mae Kelley, of Washington. He is survived by sister Calisia Kelley, as well as a niece, aunts, uncles, cousins and his grandmother.
In lieu of flowers, donations can be made to the family. Arrangements are being handled by Cremation and Funeral Care, 3287 Washington Road, McMurray.
Karen Kane and Linda Wilson Fuoco contributed. Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.
The Port Authority’s use-of-force (top) and K-9 policies:





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.