Authorities said Joseph Swidorsky told them various versions of how his 5-week-old daughter fractured her skull and died at a West View home in June.
But in court Friday, the infant’s mother testified that Mr. Swidorsky said nothing when she asked him, “What did you do to my baby?” after she found Mr. Swidorsky holding the infant, pale and unresponsive.
Mr. Swidorsky, 30, of the city’s Brighton Heights section, is charged with criminal homicide and endangering the welfare of a child in the June death of Braelyn Swidorsky. District Judge Beth Mills ordered Mr. Swidorsky to stand trial on the charges at his preliminary hearing at City Court, Downtown.
Mr. Swidorsky was alone with Braelyn, bathing her on the morning of June 15 in the bathroom of the home in the 200 block of Martsolf Avenue. Braelyn’s mother, Ashley Cain, was in a different room with her other daughter.
Ms. Cain said she went upstairs and found Mr. Swidorsky holding the baby with his hands around her ribs. The infant was bleeding from the nose and opening and closing her mouth unnaturally, she said. She told Mr. Swidorsky to call 911, and he did.
The accounts Mr. Swidorsky gave as to what happened included one that placed blame on the first responders who were helping her, suggesting that “maybe the medics did something to her when they arrived as she was fine before they arrived,” police said in an affidavit.
Read More
Mr. Swidorsky never told police that he injured the baby. He did say, however, that the baby was crying at some point during the bath as she would normally do. All of a sudden the infant took a big gulp of air and stopped breathing, he told police.
Mr. Swidorsky put the baby on the floor and started infant CPR. When West View police Officer Joseph Connolly arrived, he checked for a pulse, found none, and restarted CPR on his own.
The Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office later determined that Braelyn died from a skull fracture and brain hemorrhaging, but a discrepancy arose as to how the infant sustained those injuries.
Ms. Cain said she believes Mr. Swidorsky struck Braelyn, causing the injuries. She said Mr. Swidorsky had previously called the infant a “psycho baby,” and said, “I can’t stand her.”
But Patrick Thomassey, Mr. Swidorsky’s attorney, said there was no evidence that Mr. Swidorsky intentionally hurt the child. He said after the hearing that Mr. Swidorsky was working the morning of the incident, and it’s possible that Braelyn was injured when he wasn’t home.
Mr. Thomassey said Mr. Swidorsky was charged because he couldn’t provide authorities with an explanation of how the child was injured.
“Lack of evidence makes him guilty of homicide?” Mr. Thomassey said.
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.