As a February deadline looms for residents to vacate 104 units in one of two Penn Plaza apartment buildings in East Liberty, at least 20 households have found new quarters.
So far, just a handful have been able to stay in the neighborhood.
Penn Plaza is slated for mixed-use redevelopment. The owner, Pennley Park South, caused a panic last summer when it began notifying residents it would not be renewing leases.
The city intervened to prevent an exodus and get concessions. The owner agreed to provide relocation allowances, an on-site office for a relocation team, and 50 percent of the tax increments from its redevelopment to a fund for new affordable housing.
The debacle brought to a head the affordable housing crisis that public officials, housing agencies and neighborhood development advocates all acknowledge.
Although Penn Plaza was half vacant last summer, mostly from attrition, its total number of units, 312, represent 12 percent of East Liberty’s entire rental composition. The monthly rents in Penn Plaza range from the $500s to the $800s.
Read More
Sixty units are occupied in the second building, and those residents must move out by March 2017. As people leave the first building, the second will have room for 20 households to buy another year on the premises.
Residents in 55 units have Section 8 vouchers, and Section 8 landlords are slim pickings these days in East Liberty, where more and more rents exceed the means even of the middle class.
A 467-square-foot studio apartment in Eastside Bond is renting for $1,126 a month — one of the least expensive units there. A one-bedroom, 558-square-foot apartment in Walnut on Highland is renting for $2,500.
In the flurry of panic set off by the lease termination letters last summer, a tenant council formed. Besides helping to negotiate the city’s deal with the owner, its members have been helping neighbors find new quarters while they search for their own.
Tenants ‘very stressed’
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette has been following the efforts of about 10 residents over the past few months as they struggle to find anything affordable in East Liberty. Most are middle-aged or older.
Robert Jamison, 64, a tenant council member, has his dibs in for an apartment in the building with a 2017 deadline and is on several waiting lists for when he has to leave there.
He has lived at Penn Plaza for eight years and in the neighborhood most of his life.
A retired heavy equipment operator for Norfolk Southern Railroad, he makes too much to qualify for low-income housing but not enough to afford East Liberty much longer, he said.
“I saw one place wanting $1,300 for a one-bedroom,” he said. “I checked out a couple of senior homes [in East Liberty],” but there’s no vacancy. “I called a place in Homestead, but if you make more than $29,000, you’re not eligible.”
“Some people have come in very stressed out,” said Ken Hawker, project manager of relocation services. “People want to stay in the East Liberty area. I’d say 90 percent.”
Instead, they are finding units in Plum, Wilkinsburg, Monroeville, Bellevue and McDonald, Washington County, he said.
Mr. Jamison has said goodbye to one neighbor who has moved to Penn Hills. Two of his neighbors found apartments in the Hill District.
Oscar Sing has visited the relocation office a few times, hoping for something to shake loose. His name is on a waiting list for an apartment in North Oakland, but he is loath to leave the neighborhood.
“I’ve lived here almost nine years,” said Mr. Sing, a retired Giant Eagle meat cutter. “I love East Liberty.”
The Choice Neighborhoods development under construction on each side of East Liberty Boulevard at Larimer Avenue will absorb 120 families now living in East Liberty Gardens, an old public housing enclave that will close as the new units are built.
Only 155 public housing units are being built there. Households with vouchers will qualify for 82 units, and 97 will be market rate.
Kendall Pelling, director of land recycling for East Liberty Development Inc., said even at half occupancy, Penn Plaza’s displacement will overwhelm existing efforts to keep people in the neighborhood.
“Penn Plaza is a housing hurricane on the horizon,” he said.
“Every table you sit at, this crisis is before you,” said Aggie Brose, deputy director of the Bloomfield-Garfield Corp. “I watched it when they were turning people out of Garfield Heights. They passed out Section 8 vouchers and said, ‘You can go anywhere, and then you can come back.’ Well, they didn’t come back, and it had a ripple effect. We lost the Fort Pitt school.”
East Liberty Development owns 32 properties it rents to people with vouchers and is building 48 new low-income units, 20 under contract with the Pittsburgh Housing Authority.
Penn Plaza residents who qualify for low-income housing will be first in line for 50 of the 65 units the Urban Redevelopment Authority plans to build as the Mellon’s Orchard project at North Euclid Avenue and Station Street, but development proposals haven’t been received yet, so they will all have to vacate Penn Plaza before it is built.
Recently, the Pittsburgh Housing Authority’s board approved allotting $10 million toward 200 new units of affordable housing. There is no timetable for when those will be built.
Making ‘a business case’
At Penn Plaza, the relocation team from Interstate Acquisition Services set up shop in a first-floor apartment in November. The city brought the nonprofit Neighborhood Allies in to help residents find social services and resources, including home-ownership options.
Zak Thomas, senior program officer for the Local Initiatives Support Corp., in a dual role with Neighborhood Allies, is trying to encourage more landlords to accept Section 8 vouchers.
With so many people searching East Liberty with vouchers, he said, “we want to make a business case for this.”
The relocation staff has listed all available units it can identify by category — veterans, elders, the disabled. They post updates multiple times a day.
At the first of December, few were in East Liberty. One was an efficiency for $500. Others are listed as in “the East Liberty area,” including Highland Park and Lincoln-Lemington.
Donald Thomas, who as a teen cut grass in Highland Park and worked at Nabisco “when they made cookies,” doesn’t expect to stay in East Liberty, his lifelong home, either, he said.
He is on a waiting list for New Pennley Place, across from Penn Plaza, but also for Hazelwood Towers, the Pressley Street high-rise on the North Side and various ACTION-Housing units.
“You put as many applications as you can and wait and see,” he said. “Time is against us.”
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.