Years before he became the first mayor of Pittsburgh, military officer Ebenezer Denny was patrolling the wilderness of the new American republic when he wrote this brief journal entry for Dec. 25, 1785:

“A very dull Christmas (Sunday).”

Which raises the question: Compared with what? What would a normal, non-dull Christmas have been like in the early days at the Forks of the Ohio?

Quite different from today, but perhaps not entirely unfamiliar. Even then there was the tension between holy day and holiday, between piety and party. And this was before the popularization of Santa Claus and Christmas trees, not to mention Black Friday.

Advertise with us

In the colonial era and the early American republic, Christmas is “not going to look anything like what you think of as a Christmas celebration,” said Joan Gundersen, archivist for the Episcopal Diocese of Pittsburgh. “Almost everything we associate as a Christmas celebration is added in the middle half of the 19th century.”

The first recorded English observation of Christmas west of the Alleghenies likely took place in 1750 in central Ohio at the Native American settlement of Muskingum. Explorer Christopher Gist recorded in his diary how he read from the liturgies of the Church of England to a gathering of white traders and, via an interpreter, to members of the Wyandot tribe.

In 1754, the French built Fort Duquesne at what is now the Point in Pittsburgh. Catholic priests there would have presided at Christmas Mass under the long-standing church liturgical calendar. Although the French military chaplain, Father Denys Baron, did not leave record of such a Mass, he did record baptizing twin babies on Dec. 25, 1756.

The English troops who took over what became Fort Pitt would have brought their own prayer books from the Church of England, which also had rubrics for Christmas observances.

On the secular side, both the French and the English troops might have received a bigger rum ration on Christmases to relieve the austerity of frontier life.

Advertise with us

As civilians began settling in southwestern Pennsylvania, some might have celebrated with a fancy dinner, drinking, dancing and firing off guns, much as their fellow citizens had for generations in the more settled coastal areas.

Christmases “looked a lot more like New Year’s Day, other than the football,” Ms. Gundersen said.

Religiously, the picture was more mixed. Devout Scots-Irish Presbyterians and German evangelicals, who were among the most prominent early settlers, would have scorned the Christmas boozing and dancing, and even didn’t see precedent in the Bible for a spiritual commemoration.

“Both churches were then a bit austere in their theologies, which might have limited their ‘celebrations’ to less-than-demonstrative activities,” said Donn Neal, archivist at Smithfield United Church of Christ in Downtown, with roots in 18th-century German evangelical settlement.

But some early Protestant settlers here did bring a tradition of Christmas, including German Lutherans and members of the Church of England and its post-independence offshoot, the Episcopal Church.

Advertise with us

The wealthy Gen. John Neville would have celebrated Christmas with dinner at home (until the mansion was torched in 1794 in the Whiskey Rebellion). And he would have worshiped at the simple wooden predecessor to today’s stone Old St. Luke’s in Carnegie, according to its current vicar, the Rev. Richard Davies. The historic Episcopal sanctuary had a pre-Christmas service on Sunday, with some readers wearing vintage costumes.

In 1808, when Christmas fell on a Sunday, the new Trinity Church (now the Episcopal cathedral in Downtown) recorded the baptisms of four children. The worshipers would have used the Christmas Scriptures and readings under the rubrics of the prayer book, Ms. Gundersen said.

Even before the construction of church buildings and the arrival of ordained clergy, Episcopal lay persons could and did lead services from the Book of Common Prayer, Ms. Gundersen said.

The earliest version of the Episcopal prayer book, dating from 1789, includes a couple of Christmas hymns, including “When Shepherds Watched their Flocks by Night.”

Subsequent editions in the 19th century steadily expanded the Christmas hymns and readings as Episcopalians and others began embracing the holiday with greater ardor. That includes famous Christmas carols such as “We Three Kings” by native Pittsburgher and Episcopal cleric John Henry Hopkins Jr., the son of an Episcopal bishop and a German Lutheran mother.

Advertise with us

And as various immigrants began to assimilate into American culture, so did their traditions of Santa Claus, evergreen trees, candles and other Christmas fare.

In the early 1800s, the Pittsburgh Weekly Gazette included a handful of references to Christmas — enough to show that everyone knew when and what it was.

In 1806, the Office of Discount and Deposit at Pittsburgh published a notice saying it “will not be open for business on Christmas day.”

In 1809, the paper noted, “Christmas times are said to be proper occasions for mirth and relaxation from care.” When the War of 1812 got underway, one writer warned that an invasion of Canada “won’t be a Christmas frolick,” which it wasn’t.

And some still disapproved of such frolics. After the Panic of 1819, one writer blamed the economic collapse on Americans gone soft: “Our sons and daughters thought too much of such things as green peas at Christmas and flowered pound cake for parties,” the article said.

Advertise with us

But soon enough, Christmas was good for business. In 1829, merchant Isaac Harris advertised: “French, German and American Goods, just received, a large variety of Fancy Articles, suitable for the ... approaching Christmas and New Year’s Sales,” including beads, watch chains, keys, toy watches, pocket looking glasses, snuff-boxes, needle cases and dozens of other items.

And at Market and Fourth streets, readers in 1831 were invited at Christmastime to the “magnificently decorated” Pennsylvania Museum with flowers, evergreens, music and “artificial fireworks and phantasmagoria.” Admission was 25 cents for adults, half that for children.

From there, it’s a straight line to opening presents in the morning and going to “Star Wars” in the afternoon.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.