While the Hunt Armory in Shadyside no longer serves as a military training center and storage space for weapons and ammunition, a real battle has erupted over its potential reuse.
As a possible vote looms Thursday, one Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority board member backed a plan Tuesday to convert the armory to residential use, while the city councilman who represents Shadyside embraced a proposal to turn it into an ice rink.
The conflicting views arose as the URA board prepares to vote Thursday to award exclusive negotiations to one of three competing bidders for the rights to redevelop the Emerson Street landmark.
A URA agenda released Tuesday in advance of the meeting did not list a recommendation. “My hope is that we will work to come to a consensus on Thursday,” board chairman Kevin Acklin said.
In a statement Tuesday, one URA board member, former state Sen. Jim Ferlo, said he’s opposed to the ice rink proposed by Kratsa Properties and Cadan Inc. He favors a plan by Walnut Capital and Massaro Properties to convert the armory into 106 apartments.
Mr. Ferlo, who nominated the structure for a city historic designation, said Walnut Capital is offering $1.8 million, the minimum sales price, for the building, while Kratsa bid $1 million.
Read More
He also favors the residential plan based on “principles of preservation, sustainability, positive economic impact for the city and school district as well as detrimental impact issues affecting adjoining residential property owners.”
The Kratsa proposal, he maintained, did not meet the requirements outlined in the request for proposals issued by the URA.
“I cannot vote in favor of the ice rink developers or the proposal they submitted because they have failed their due diligence and their concept will have the greatest detrimental impact, is not sustainable based on the financial plan they submitted, and I do not believe the commonwealth will give final approval,” Mr. Ferlo wrote.
The state, which had owned the building before conveying it to the URA for $1, would receive 80 percent of whatever is obtained in a resale of the structure.
If the city is serious about putting a public amenity like an ice rink in the armory, the URA should delay Thursday’s vote, issue a new request for proposals and open the process to private entities, nonprofits and even city government, Mr. Ferlo said.
While Mr. Ferlo raised objections to the ice rink, Councilman Dan Gilman endorsed it. In a letter to URA board members, he said the plan “provides a different and creative opportunity for the building.”
“This project would create the only indoor ice rink in the city of Pittsburgh. It would meet a critical need for local skaters and hockey teams, introduce the sport to a new generation, and create an important community engagement opportunity in the middle of the booming East End,” he wrote.
Mr. Gilman said that of the hundreds of communications he received regarding the armory’s reuse, more than 95 percent favored the ice rink proposal. An online petition has attracted more than 1,000 signatures, he added.
“In my 12 years in city hall, this is by far the greatest community engagement I have seen on any issue and it has been overwhelmingly in support of the ice rink development,” he said.
Not everyone is as enthusiastic. Residents of the Alder Court co-op building next to the armory are concerned about the noise and traffic the ice rink would generate.
Deborah McCormick, a member of the co-op’s board of directors, said to be viable, the rink likely would have to operate 18 hours a day. Many practices and league games would be early in the morning or late at night, she said.
“We think the ice rink proposal would have the most negative impact on the quality of life for the most immediate neighbors,” she said.
The other proposal for the armory redevelopment was submitted by McKnight Realty Partners and the Mosites Co. They are proposing a business incubator built around 120,000 to 140,000 square feet of collaborative office space. There are also plans for a climbing wall and other recreational and community-oriented space.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.