There was a little something for everyone in the report state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale presented Tuesday on the Pittsburgh Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority, the board of political appointees that has been the bane of Mayor Bill Peduto’s second year in office.
For the authority, created in 2004 by the state legislature to keep tabs on the city’s finances as it entered the Act 47 program for distressed municipalities, there was acknowledgement that its work had “made a positive difference” in Pittsburgh’s financial recovery and validation that it had exclusive control over what is at present nearly $13 million in gaming revenue that Mr. Peduto’s administration has sued to release.
The authority’s political patrons in Harrisburg, Senate President Pro Tem Joseph Scarnati, R-Jefferson, and Speaker of the House Mike Turzai, R-Marshall, whose appointments to the ICA board are the only remaining members on the five-member panel, found “substantial affirmation of the success of the ICA."
But perhaps the best news was reserved for Mr. Peduto’s administration, which has been attempting to rid the city of the authority since last spring, when it asked the state Department of Community and Economic Development to dissolve the ICA, arguing it had outlived its founding statute, which directed the state to terminate the authority after the city had “annual operating budgets and five-year financial plans approved by the board for at least the three immediately preceding years.”
Mr. DePasquale said those criteria had been met and the city should negotiate a deal with the governor and legislative leaders that makes the authority disappear in exchange for the city’s commitment to devote all of the roughly $10 million it gets a year in gaming money to its pension fund, which is about 58 percent funded.
He was asked if there was a reason for the authority to exist if the city makes that pledge, which Mr. Peduto’s administration says it is willing to do.
Read More
“The answer to that question is no,” Mr. DePasquale said.
Both the governor's office and the Department of Community and Economic Development said they would examine the report as part of their review of the ICA.
'Mind-numbing'
Until that time, however, he called on the city and the authority, which also must approve the city budget every year, to put aside more than a year’s worth of acrimony and cooperate. Given the lawsuit, the city contention that the ICA board’s actions are invalid because it cannot assemble a quorum and rock-bottom levels of trust between the entities, he acknowledged that might be a rocky road.
The authority needs to clearly articulate conditions for getting the gaming money and the city should work to meet them, he said.
“They keep attacking each other in the paper and meanwhile … it gets into a he-said he-said,” Mr. DePasquale said. “It’s mind-numbing.”
Mr. DePasquale’s report also refereed other points of contention in the city and authority’s fraught relationship, criticizing the ICA for retroactively revoking its approval of the 2015 budget in a move that strained the limits of logic and calling on the authority to “ensure that all board decisions are enacted during public meetings” and “immediately begin to follow the Commonwealth’s Procurement Code as a best practice.”
The mayor’s office has accused the ICA of doling out no-bid contracts to politically firms, contrary to state bidding and contracting laws.
“The Peduto administration is correct that they weren’t done that way. But the ICA actually, according to the law, didn’t have to do that. We believe they should.” Mr. DePasquale said.
'Poor Record-Keeping'
Authority Executive Director Henry Sciortino, the ICA’s sole employee and beneficiary of the lion’s share of its roughly $230,000 a year budget, was unable to produce copies of all of the contracts the ICA has executed, only a listing of contractors and a schedule of payments.
“We found no political favoritism, but by the same token, I’m sure the city will say we couldn’t get all the information,” Mr. DePasquale said. “We’re not a criminal justice agency. What we found was evidence of poor record-keeping.”
Mr. DePasquale blamed the authority’s founding legislation and the limits of Mr. Sciortino’s one-man operation.
“We could go back in time and start throwing stones. I am concerned. I wish it had not happened that way. … I think there could have been better organization in the office as well,” he said. “The state legislature and the governor should never, ever, ever pass a law in the future that creates an authority that it isn’t clear that that authority is subject to the state’s Right to Know law and the state procurement law. That is an unconscionable decision or lack of decision when this law was passed.”
ICA Chairman Nicholas Varischetti took that as vindication.
“It is now clear from the auditor general's report that there is simply no evidence to support Mayor Peduto's claims of inappropriate or political favoritism in the ICA's procurement practices. At the same time, Mr. DePasquale is correct that the ICA has a responsibility to do a better job of record keeping,” Mr. Varischetti wrote in a statement, asking the city to drop its “meritless legal claim” and submit to the ICA’s conditions for receiving the gaming money. While the report “outlines a recommendation for a path that includes an end to independent fiscal oversight of Pittsburgh, that is a decision that can only be made by our legislative leaders in Harrisburg,” he added. “ I certainly respect the auditor general's recommendation on this matter and will defer to our leaders in Harrisburg on the need for continued oversight.”
Mr. Peduto is scheduled to meet next week with legislative leaders including Mr. Scarnati, and Mr. Turzai, who put out a joint statement Tuesday.
“We firmly believe that in order for the city of Pittsburgh to continue on a path toward financial recovery the ICA must have involvement moving forward," the statement says. "We look forward to meeting with Mayor Peduto at the Capitol next week to discuss recommendations of the audit and how we can all work together to strengthen the relationship between the city of Pittsburgh and the Pittsburgh ICA.”
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter: @rczullo.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.