With the wide eyes of a fastball hitter who guessed right, Mark E. Mitchell stared at his computer screen. The auction was for a 1930s bat used by the Pittsburgh Crawfords, one of the best baseball teams ever assembled. Bids hovered near the $300 starting price.

“The bidding was so sparse. I’m thinking this could be Josh Gibson’s bat,” said Mr. Mitchell, a dealer and appraiser of historic newspapers.

The Bradenton, Fla., man, who also collects African-American cultural artifacts, considers this battered, cracked piece of white ash that he bought for $1,126 in 2009 one of the most important items in his 4,000-piece collection.

Now he’s rooting for one more home run, returning the bat to the city and the people that made it famous. “I think it should come back to Pittsburgh. It makes so much sense.”

Advertise with us

Rather than auction it, Mr. Mitchell would like to sell the bat directly to an institution or individual who would put it on display. He was thinking of the Pittsburgh Pirates or Western Pennsylvania Sports Museum.

“We are interested in finding out more information on this piece of Pittsburgh baseball history in order to explore the possibility of acquiring it for public display at the ballpark,” said Brian Warecki, Pirates vice president of communications.

The sports museum, part of the Heinz History Center in the Strip District, has a large area devoted to Pittsburgh’s two Negro League teams, the Crawfords and Homestead Grays. The museum would love to receive it as a donation, said Ned Schano, director of communications.

Mr. Mitchell believes the bat is worth as much as ones used by Babe Ruth or Lou Gehrig that sell at auction for hundreds of thousands of dollars. Based on the initials C.W. written on it, he believes it belonged to Chester Williams, a shortstop known more for his fielding than batting, Nonetheless, he hit .383 in 1937 and was voted by fans to four East-West all-star games.

“This brings the Crawfords and Grays alive to people,” he said.

Advertise with us

But how does Mr. Mitchell know the bat was used by the Crawfords, a 1930s powerhouse that routinely battled the Grays for the Negro National League pennant? Because it bears the name of the man who built the team by swiping five future hall of famers from other Negro League teams — numbers racketeer William A. “Gus” Greenlee. Written in ink upon the bat are the words: W.A. Greenlee 5-8-35 Negro Nat. Pittsburgh PA.

Bat authenticators say this “side writing” indicates that Greenlee sent the bat back to its maker, Hillerich & Bradsby Co. in Louisville, Ky., so more like it could be made. Many white Major League Baseball teams and players did this. If a player had signed a contract with the company — the Pirates’ Honus Wagner was the first Louisville Slugger in 1905 — he received bats with his signature burned into the barrel. But black players, who were barred from the majors until Jackie Robinson in 1947, couldn’t get bats with their signatures.

The best they could hope for was a professionally hand-turned bat with their name stamped on it. Troy Kinunen, president of authentications at Memorabilia Evaluation and Research Services in Milwaukee, has seen only a handful of name-stamped Negro League bats in his 20-year career. Few had side writing, and none mentioned Mr. Greenlee.

“Negro League bats are super rare,” he said, and this one is even rarer.

Mr. Kinunen, whose company tried to auction the Crawfords bat months before Mr. Mitchell bought it, has authenticated a 1935 Spalding bat stamped “J. Gibson” that was sent to Hillerich & Bradsby as a template. Mr. Gibson, a hall of fame slugger and catcher who played for both the Crawfords and the Grays, asked for more bats like it. The Gibson bat is now part of an online collection, the National Pastime Museum (www.thenationalpastimemuseum.com).

Advertise with us

Mr. Kinunen said the Gibson bat is so unique that it’s “close to priceless.” He said the Crawfords bat is “not in the same ballpark.” A more comparable bat might be a 1927-30 H&B bat with side writing indicating it belonged to Jud Wilson, a hall of famer who played for the Crawfords and Grays. SCP Auctions sold it for $3,515 in May 2012.

The Crawfords bat has a 14-inch-long crack and the burned-in signature of Jimmie Foxx, a white hall of famer. Its construction and the “36” stamped on the knob indicate it was a store-bought bat, said Dave Grob, a baseball memorabilia researcher in Woodbridge, Va.

“They probably bought a couple bats from a sporting goods store. The players liked them and said, ‘Let’s get some more.’ ”

In May 1935, Mr. Greenlee ordered nine bats — three like this one and six 37-inchers, according to orders on file at the Louisville Slugger Museum & Factory.

“He asked for 125 wood, which was our top-quality wood,” said museum curator Chris Meiman.

Advertise with us

Kevin Kirkland: 412-263-1978 or kkirkland@post-gazette.com.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.