State Superior Court judges said Tuesday they will review a dashboard video of the traffic stop that preceded the 2012 shooting of Leon Ford by Pittsburgh police to decide the merits of his appeal of his conviction for traffic violations.

Officer David Derbish shot and paralyzed Mr. Ford, 22, of Shaler in November 2012 after the stop in Highland Park.

Officer Derbish said he fired in self-defense.

A jury acquitted Mr. Ford last year on charges of assaulting police but deadlocked on lesser charges, and the district attorney’s office decided not to retry him.

Advertise with us

But Common Pleas Judge Donald Machen also had convicted him of summary offenses of failure to yield and careless driving, which are the subjects of Mr. Ford’s appeal.

His lawyer, Fred Rabner, and assistant district attorney Michael Streily briefly argued before a three-judge panel whether the traffic stop was legal.

Mr. Streily said that it was and that the video shows Mr. Ford driving through a stop sign.

But Mr. Rabner said the video, recorded from hundreds of feet away, shows him applying his brakes at a stop sign, putting his turn signal on and then making a turn.

In questioning the lawyers on the circumstances of the stop, the Superior Court judges also asked why the police were driving the wrong way down a one-way street when Mr. Ford’s car passed them.

Advertise with us

Neither side had an explanation, but Mr. Rabner said after the hearing that “they should have cited themselves” instead of his client.

He said it could be a month or so before the Superior Court makes a decision.

Meanwhile, Mr. Ford’s civil rights suit against the police, filed in 2013, is pending in U.S. District Court.

Both sides have most recently been sparring over depositions, with Mr. Rabner’s office seeking an order to compel depositions of assistant district attorney Robert Schupansky, who tried the Ford case, along with Rebecca Spangler, the first assistant district attorney, and Dennis Logan, chief of investigations. Among other claims, Mr. Rabner says the DA’s office and city police have been working together to “persecute” Mr. Ford.

The district attorney’s office objected to that characterization, saying that it has nothing to do with Mr. Ford’s 14th Amendment complaint against the police.

Advertise with us

Attorney Bernard Schneider, who represents the district attorney’s office, said the attempts to depose the DA’s officials “show that the plaintiff's attorneys are desperately scrounging to find evidence implicating” the DA in Mr. Ford’s injuries.

Last week, U.S. Magistrate Judge Maureen Kelly sided with Mr. Ford, granting a motion to compel the depositions.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.