Some of the most harrowing stories from school shootings are of gunmen mowing down students and teachers huddling under desks or jammed into closets.
Though experts agree fleeing or hiding are the first things those confronted with a shooter should do, a new approach is that some circumstances call for fighting back as the best strategy for survival. In the wake of yet another mass shooting at Umpqua Community College in Oregon that left nine dead, those who work to prepare others for such horrible moments say action is sometimes needed.
“It used to be about being quiet and sitting in the corner and hoping that the bad person doesn’t find you. But now, ultimately what we encourage people to do is fight back. Don’t just sit in the corner and hope that the bad thing doesn’t happen to you,” said Mt. Lebanon police Chief Aaron Lauth.
Locally, safety officials in elementary and secondary schools and on college campuses are training not just staff, but students as well, to fight back if cornered by an active shooter.
The safety experts say it’s important for school staff and students to take action on their own because statistics show that most active shooter situations are over within about five minutes — often before police arrive. And, they say, experience has shown that obeying the commands of the shooters does not save the lives of victims.
Most of the school and college safety experts refer to ALICE training, an acronym that stands for Alert, Lockdown, Inform, Counter, Evacuate. Under the training, teachers and students are taught that in the event of an emergency such as an active shooter or other dangerous intruder, they should evacuate if they can and if not, lock down and barricade in place.
But if those options aren’t available and the teachers and students are confronted by an active shooter, the training instructs them to fight back by throwing objects, shouting, moving around, distracting and if possible taking down the attacker.
“If you are just sitting there doing nothing you have increased the probability of being shot,” said Jim Modrak, Bethel Park school police officer. “The research shows that these are not hostage situations. They are acts of violence and they are there to kill as many people as they can.”
In Mt. Lebanon, police have trained staff, middle and high school students in how to deal with an active shooter. In Bethel Park, students were trained in the first two phases of ALICE training last school year and this fall will participate in drills on fighting back against an attacker, said Officer Modrak.
In Quaker Valley, students from kindergarten through 12th grade will receive ALICE training, said school police officer Aaron Vanatta.
Officer Vanatta said in the past there was controversy over whether training students to prepare for attackers would frighten them.
“But we teach kids at a very young age to stop, drop and roll in a fire and about stranger danger. For these other tragedies we teach kids to be proactive and not passive. It’s time to teach them about fighting intruders,” Officer Vanatta said.
College students are also being taught how to fight back against an attacker.
Since the 2007 Virginia Tech massacre, the deadliest mass shooting in U.S. history, Duquesne University has required active shooter/violence on-campus training for resident life staff and provided sessions for students as requested, said school spokeswoman Bridget Fare. Starting last fall, the school expanded its number of training sessions, with a focus on the “Run Hide Fight" concept.
At California University, ALICE training was part of the freshman orientation, said police Chief Edward McSheffery. It will be made available to other students through training sessions that will be advertised throughout the campus. Staff and campus police already have been trained.
He said students and staff are encouraged to throw bookbags, fire extinguishers and even desks at intruders.
A review of ALICE, training occurs at Carlow University once a semester.
In public school districts, officials said they take great care in the training of younger students so as not to instill fear. In Mt. Lebanon, elementary students are taught drills by their teachers. The biggest lesson is that they must be quiet and listen to the teacher’s directions.
But in the upper grades, “the older kids have the ability size-wise to swarm and disable an intruder. The younger kids will rely more on throwing things and yelling and screaming and moving and not being targets — anything to break down the shooter’s mental process,” Officer Modrak said.
In the Mt. Lebanon School District staff can connect to the public address system from any school phone. In the event of an emergency, an adult can announce to everyone in the school what the emergency is and where it is happening.
That information, Chief Lauth said, can help those in the building decide how to react. If they are a distance from the emergency, they can choose to evacuate. If they are close, they can choose to barricade in their rooms and prepare for a possible intruder.
“Information sharing is crucial,” he said.
Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com. Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.