Three Oakland residents say a Pittsburgh policewoman verbally abused them, threatened to arrest one of them for trying to record a confrontation and then filed false charges of disorderly conduct against them after they made formal complaints about her.

In a federal civil rights suit brought Tuesday by the American Civil Liberties Union, the residents say Officer Elizabeth Vitalbo abused her power during and after an incident in Oakland on Sept. 28, 2013.

Teresa Brown of Ward Street, her daughters Monica Jackson and Pamela Brown, and her neighbor, Anthony Grace, said they were on Ms. Brown’s porch when they saw a group of men fighting in the street nearby. Ms. Brown walked over and broke it up, after which Officer Vitalbo arrived in response to a call from another neighbor.

Ms. Brown, a constable, explained that she broke up the fight and indicated the direction in which the fighters ran. Officer Vitalbo started walking in that direction but came back, saying she could hear Ms. Brown and the others shouting profanely on the porch, and told them to “shut up,” according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

Officer Vitalbo then accused Ms. Brown of lying about where the fight happened, threatened to arrest her and also threatened to label her house as a nuisance property.

Ms. Brown said she responded that she is a constable and that she and the officer are on the “same side,” to which Officer Vitalbo responded with a profanity and that she didn’t care, the complaint says.

At that point, Ms. Jackson took out her cell phone and said she was going to record the confrontation but stopped when Officer Vitalbo threatened to arrest her.

Officer Vitalbo called for backup, after which 15 to 20 officers arrived. One of them grabbed Mr. Grace and slammed him against the porch railing and ordered him to sit down, the complaint says. After an hour, the officers left without citing anyone.

The three plaintiffs filed complaints two days later with the Office of Municipal Investigations against Officer Vitalbo, saying she was “rude, falsely identified herself, did not allow Ms. Jackson to use her cell phone to record the officer, and acted unprofessionally.”

Advertise with us

Two months later, the ACLU sent a letter to the acting police chief, Regina McDonald, asking her to make sure that Officer Vitalbo and all officers are aware that under the First Amendment, citizens have a right to record police in the performance of their duties.

OMI closed its case in March 2014, finding the complaints unfounded.

Shortly before that decision, Ms. Brown, Ms. Jackson and Mr. Grace received disorderly conduct citations for ”unreasonable noise“ from the Sept. 28 incident. All three were found not guilty in city court, according to the complaint.

The ACLU and the attorney who filed the suit, Timothy O’Brien, said the citations appeared to be retaliation for the complaints to OMI.

‘‘This incident reflects the unfortunate and unconstitutional custom and practice of Pittsburgh police unnecessarily and illegally misusing their authority to intimidate and coerce innocent, law-abiding civilians who question or challenge the improper police behavior,” wrote Mr. O’Brien.

Advertise with us

Mr. O’Brien said Tuesday that the police department has been aware since a court loss in the mid-1990s that citizens are allowed to record police.

“They’ve known for 20 years,” he said.

In that case, Associated Press freelance photographer Charles Palla was arrested in 1992 for interfering with the arrest of a homeless man in a parking lot. Police confiscated his film and returned it three days later with 14 photos developed and 22 frames exposed.

A judge dismissed a criminal case against Mr. Palla, but he sued. In 1996, a jury awarded him $101,000 in damages.

The city law department said it hadn’t yet seen the ACLU suit.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.