Federal authorities are investigating a claim by Matthews International Corp. that a former employee stole more than $14 million from the company over many years.
The U.S. attorney’s office confirmed federal agents are examining the claim, which the North Shore-based company disclosed in its third-quarter financial report July 30.
The prosecutors’ office would not reveal the former employee’s name, nor would Matthews.
But her lawyer, Phil DiLucente, said she is Cindy Mills of McKees Rocks, who is in her 50s and formerly worked in the company’s Bronze Division accounting office until she was fired two months ago. Matthews has 10,000 employees around the globe; its Bronze Division on West Liberty Avenue makes burial products.
“She is being investigated,” Mr. DiLucente said of his client, but would not comment further.
Ann Wilson, director of communications for Matthews, would only say that the U.S. attorney’s office is investigating and has identified a suspect.
Matthews said in July that in the previous quarter it had identified the theft of $14.8 million by an employee “over a multi-year period through May 2015.” The company would not specify the length of time, but it is believed to be 17 years. If the allegations are true, the case would be one of the largest embezzlement prosecutions in the history of federal court here.
Matthews said it expects to recover the loss “primarily through insurance and recovery of assets” and said it is working with law enforcement. It’s not clear which federal agency is investigating, although with a theft so large it’s likely that multiple agencies are involved.
The company also said the board of directors, through its audit committee, immediately began its own investigation with an independent lawyer and accounting support. The company said no managers were involved and that the thefts have been determined to “constitute a material weakness in internal controls” that Matthews has since corrected.
Matthews has been victimized before by its local employees.
Most recently, Peter Kalemon of Aliquippa, the former traffic manager at Matthews, was sentenced in January to 33 months in federal prison and ordered to repay $415,000 that he systematically stole from 2010 to 2013 in a bogus invoice scheme.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.