When Pittsburgh police created plans to reorganize parts of the bureau in hopes of stemming recent violence and improving solve rates, they used, knowingly or not, some ideas tried by previous administrations.

Police Chief Cameron McLay and a string of supervisors in the department outlined Tuesday plans to merge the bureau’s homicide and robbery squads into one group called the Violent Crime Unit beginning in September. The idea, they said, was to set aside 15 more detectives to focus on solving killings, of which there have been 30 so far this year, and an additional six to focus on aggravated assaults.

Police also announced a formalized policy outlining how the neighborhood stations should respond to increases in shootings and other violent crimes.

“You can’t solve old problems with old ways,” Mayor Bill Peduto said during a news conference announcing the changes. “Simply putting more boots on the ground is not really a solution to being able to solve any crime, and certainly not violent crime.”

Advertise with us

But to some who have worked in the bureau, the plans didn’t seem new.

Former police Chief Robert McNeilly said that when he was a commander in 1990s the bureau tried combining the homicide and robbery units and then split them apart when the idea proved less effective than hoped. He said he wasn't entirely positive why the idea didn’t work because the bureau didn’t hold meetings among commanders then as it does now.

Chief McLay pitched the merger as a way to increase manpower in the strapped detectives units.

“When I first came in, I was seeing we were fairly generously staffed in investigations as compared to the streets, and we needed to shift resources out there,” he said. “I cut too deep. We were robbing Peter to pay Paul and recognized the mistake and realized we needed staff.”

In addition to creating a Violent Crime Unit, the bureau also will eliminate its Night Felony Unit, which helped process crime scenes during the overnight shift, and move its detectives into a Mobile Crime Unit, which serves the same function during the day and evening shifts.

Advertise with us

Assistant Chief of Operations Scott Schubert announced the formalization of a three-pronged policy that outlines how the city’s neighborhood stations should respond to violence and threats.

The first level is triggered when officers receive tangible threats of violence in a particular area. A commander who hears, for example, that there is a threat in a specific neighborhood might send extra officers to patrol there.

The second level is triggered when an act of violence, such as a shooting or killing, happens. In such cases, police leaders might authorize overtime to increase the number of officers working in the area. Last week, they sent one car from each neighborhood station to help patrol the North Side between 4 p.m. and 8 a.m. following a string of shootings there, according to Chief Schubert. During those same hours of the day, there was a shooting in Homewood that left a 12-year-old child in critical condition and a killing in Crafton Heights.

The third level of the policy begins when officers receive word that violence might be retaliatory, and suspect there is likely to be more of it. For example, if they suspect a string of shootings are retaliatory and a homicide victim’s friends or relatives are likely to be targeted, they might adjust their manpower to account for the deceased person’s funeral.

In such cases, police also might seek help from other agencies, such as the Allegheny County Sheriff’s Office, local probation and parole units, the FBI and others.

Advertise with us

Catherine McNeilly, who recently retired as a Pittsburgh police commander, said, “It doesn’t sound like anything new, not to me anyway.” Both she and her husband said they wish the bureau well and hope the changes help.

The new plans received mixed reactions from some whose relatives have been killed in the city and whose cases remain, like many, unsolved.

Joy Renee Burgwin has been waiting for five years for an arrest in the death of her brother, Sean Murphy, who was helping to transport gifts from a relative’s baby shower when someone shot through the window of his SUV while he sat in traffic.

Ms. Burgwin said her brother had been robbed prior to his death, and the family suspects his killing is connected to that robbery, as well as to the death of another man in West Virginia, an angle she wished police had examined harder.

“We gave them lots of leads,” she said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Burgwin said detectives told her they weren’t able to obtain enough evidence from surveillance footage and, “They need a witness.”

She said she’d like to see a larger emphasis on solving “cold cases” — something Chief McLay said he hopes to do if given more officers — and see police work more with community members who are willing to pass along information but not necessarily to testify.

“My mom wants answers. We want answers,” she said. “It’s been five years. I know that his case is cold.”