Sen. John McCain, R-Arizona, said Monday that Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump doesn’t need to apologize to him for remarks about his captivity in Vietnam, but Mr. Trump should tell veterans and their families that he’s sorry.
“When Mr. Trump says he prefers to be with people who are not captured, the great honor of my life was to be in the company of heroes,” Mr. McCain said on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe.” The occasionally fiery senator, a onetime presidential candidate himself, calmly said: “I am not a hero.”
But some of the thousands of veterans gathered in Pittsburgh for the Veterans of Foreign Wars annual convention disagree.
John Biedrzycki — a Robinson veteran who on Wednesday will be elevated to national commander, the VFW’s top post — called Mr. Trump’s remarks “ludicrous.”
“A man serving his nation in a military operation is shot down and imprisoned and tortured,” Mr. Biedrzycki said of Mr. McCain. “What’s [Mr. Trump’s] next statement? To say [Mr. McCain] should have been wounded and killed” to be considered a hero?
“He’s never served, he doesn’t know how it feels, what it takes, the sacrifice that we go through,” Army Staff Sgt. Chris Fielding said of Mr. Trump. “I don’t think he has a right to say that. I think he’s just saying it to get some attention.”
Read More
Mr. Trump, who made his remarks about Mr. McCain at a conservative forum last week in Iowa, has refused to back off his statements and instead leveled new criticism against the 2008 GOP presidential nominee, saying Mr. McCain had made America “less safe” through his votes in Congress.
“The reality is that John McCain the politician has made America less safe, sent our brave soldiers into wrongheaded foreign adventures, covered up for President [Barack] Obama with the VA scandal and has spent most of his time in the Senate pushing amnesty,” Mr. Trump wrote in an opinion piece in Monday’s USA Today. “He would rather protect the Iraqi border than Arizona’s.”
In a contentious interview Monday on NBC’s “Today” show, Mr. Trump took issue with the media’s reporting on his comments about Mr. McCain’s war record. He insisted in a telephone interview with anchor Matt Lauer that he had said “four times” that he respected those captured in war.
But Jim Roddey, chairman of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County and a former Marine, said Mr. Trump had “really insulted all veterans, and he should not be a candidate for the presidency.”
Mr. Roddey said Mr. Trump’s comments have put the GOP in a difficult position, as he is leading polls. But a president needs to speak for all, he said.
“I think the first thing you have to be is honest, and I simply do not believe that he represents what Americans feel about their veterans and prisoners of war and people that have served and are serving in the armed forces,” Mr. Roddey said.
Some veterans, however, are taking the remarks in stride as part of the political game.
“It was the media exploding just a section of what he said and taken completely out of context,” said Marine veteran Ed Southern. “I listened to the whole thing, and he did not say it the way they reported it.”
Vietnam veteran Marty Moore said he still supports Mr. Trump politically despite his criticism of Mr. McCain.
“Every candidate has baggage,” the Army veteran said. “Every one of them, you like something.”
One thing Mr. Moore said he likes about Mr. Trump is that he has taken a stand on issues other candidates have avoided, such as immigration.
Vietnam veteran Donald Young said he supported Mr. Trump on certain issues, but Mr. Trump’s rhetoric has now turned him away.
“I haven’t made my mind up who I’m going to vote for,” Mr. Young said. “But if I was voting today, no, I wouldn’t vote for Trump.”
Mr. McCain noted the context of the comments directed at him.
“I’m in the [political] arena,” he said on “Morning Joe,” suggesting he’s fair game for criticism as a U.S. senator. “The best thing to do is put it behind us and move forward.”
Mr. Roddey had a different idea: “I wish that we could have Donald Trump in Marine Corps boot camp at Parris Island for about one week, starting with a recruit haircut and ending up on a 30-mile march.”
Post-Gazette writer Sean D. Hamill and The Associated Press contributed. Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.