A Philadelphia developer has big plans to recruit retailers, restaurants and entertainment to replace a departing Macy’s Downtown, but some wonder whether it will be enough to fill the void left by the loss of the department store.

Hours after Macy’s announced its decision to close the iconic department store at Fifth Avenue and Smithfield Street, representatives for Core Realty said Monday that they intend to devote two floors to retail in the 13-floor building to complement plans for 311 apartments and a 155-room hotel.

“We think it’s something Pittsburgh is ready for and will embrace,” said Randy Mineo, Core’s executive vice president. “We’re excited about getting started with that process.”

Core is considering fashion retailers, restaurants, and entertainment, including a possible bowling alley, for the first two floors of the building, a couple hundred thousand square feet in all.

Advertise with us

Mr. Mineo said the developer is “going after the very best retailers we can find” as part of the redevelopment, expected to top $90 million. He said talks with retailers are just beginning now that Macy’s has formally announced the store’s closing.

“We feel that it’s the best location for retail in Pittsburgh. We think it’s going to be the catalyst for additional retail in the city,” he said.

In addition to the two floors of retail, Core intends to convert floors 7-13 to the apartments. It also has been talking to Reception Hotels and Resorts about a plan to put a 155-room hotel on floors 5-6. It also is proposing about 600 parking spaces in the building’s basement and on floors 3-4.

Matthew Shollar, Reception’s Pittsburgh-based partner, said the firm is still “very committed” to the project even without Macy’s and is very close to finalizing the deal for the hotel. He added the new retail mix proposed by Core may even heighten interest in the development.

For more than a year, Core has been advancing plans to keep the department store on floors 1-4 under an arrangement with Macy’s. But in the last month, leaders of the Cincinnati-based department store chain had a change of heart, resulting in the decision to close a store that generates perhaps more sentimentality from Pittsburghers than it does sales.

Advertise with us

Michael Samschick, Core owner and president, said he jumped at the chance to take over the entire building. Core paid about $15 million for it.

While sympathizing with Pittsburghers who are sad to lose the store, Mr. Samschick said he is excited about the chance “to create something unique to the Pittsburgh market.”

“We feel very lucky for that opportunity,” he said.

He was quick to stress that Core had no plans to remove the building’s famous clock, part of Pittsburgh lore.

“We would never move that clock. That is part of the history of the building. We feel it’s really impactful. We love that clock and it will not be moved,” he said.

Advertise with us

Core, he added, is “100 percent open” to keeping two other store stalwarts — Tic Toc restaurant and the Arcade Bakery. Mayor Bill Peduto tweeted Monday that he was working to save them. Macy’s intends to close both July 31, spokesman Jim Sluzewski said.

“We love the idea of preserving the Tic Toc. We love the idea of preserving the history of what was there,” Mr. Samschick said.

Mr. Peduto was notified of the store closing over the weekend, said Kevin Acklin, his chief of staff. He added the city didn’t have a chance “to participate in an opportunity to save Macy’s.”

While Mr. Acklin said the decision to close the tradition-steeped store “stings,” he noted the city was excited about the proposed Core development, saying it has a chance to “reactivate that building and be a transformational development for what we’re trying to accomplish on Smithfield Street.”

“This isn’t a situation where Macy’s is closing and the building is going to be shuttered,” he said. “This is a situation where Macy’s sold to a developer who is going to spend [$90 million] to reinvest in the building and make it part of a successful story of the revitalization of Downtown and the city. While the loss of the institution hurts, it’s not a story where the windows are boarded up and it sits there vacant for years.”

Advertise with us

Herky Pollock, a well-known retail broker in the city, maintained that the loss of Macy’s will have a “marginal to no impact” on the overall vitality of the Golden Triangle.

He said Kaufmann’s, which occupied the building for decades before Macy’s, did $95 million in sales a year during its heyday. That had dwindled to about $20 million, an indication, Mr. Pollock said, that “perhaps a large-scale department store is not the best fit for our [central business district].”

Two smaller midsized box stores, a grocery, a discount department store or several restaurants easily could replace that annual sales volume, he suggested.

“Other than the perception of losing an anchor Downtown, from a pure traffic and vitality standpoint, Macy’s will not be missed,” he said. “The best example I can give you is that many people wrote Downtown Pittsburgh off for dead when it lost three other department stores and Downtown is more vital now than it has been in the last century.”

Mr. Pollock, executive vice president of CBRE, said one thing that has held back more retail Downtown has been the lack of concentrated space for such development. Retailers generally like to be grouped together to take advantage of cross traffic.

Advertise with us

The Core redevelopment “provides an opportunity to have multiple retailers and restaurants all under one roof with great parking and the ability to do in excess of $100 million in sales versus a mere fraction of that,” he argued.

Not everybody saw a silver lining.

John Valentine, executive director of the Pittsburgh Downtown Community Development Corp., said the closing could slow down the Downtown residential renaissance.

He said his phone was ringing off the hook Monday with calls from Downtown residents wondering where they would shop or whether there were plans to bring in another department store. “There’s going to be an impact. To what degree I’m not sure. It’s sad. It’s not a good day. I’m sorry to see them go,” he said.

“It’s another amenity lost. When you move Downtown, it’s a whole lifestyle. There are a lot of people I know who sold their car or who don’t have cars. They walk everywhere or take Uber. They would shop at Macy’s. It’s another thing they’re going to have to go out of Downtown for.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Valentine was wary of Core’s plans for new retail in the building. While a mix of famous clothing brands and independent boutiques might work, “the last thing I want to see there is another Cheesecake Factory,” he said. “I hope they have enough sense to understand this is an urban village and not a mall.”

As for those who didn’t see the loss of Macy’s as a blow to Downtown? “People that are saying that don’t live Downtown,” said Mr. Valentine, who does.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.