Two Homewood brothers who say Pittsburgh police used a Taser on one of them and roughed them up without cause during a 2013 incident have sued a dozen city officers they say were involved.
In a federal suit filed this week, Will and Beyshaud El and their lawyer said city officers violated their rights on July 2, 2013, during an arrest outside a convenience store at Fletcher and Fielding ways in Homewood.
Police charged Will El, 22 at the time, and Beyshaud El, 19 at the time, with aggravated assault against an officer because, they said, the men fought with two officers. The district attorney’s office later reduced the charge against the brothers to disorderly conduct after reviewing a video of the incident that District Attorney Stephen Zappala said contradicted some of what the police said happened.
The incident began when Lt. Reyne Kacsuta stopped the brothers about 1:45 p.m. to find out if they were old enough to buy cigarettes they had purchased at the store.
Other officers came to help her. The video from a police cruiser dashboard camera shows the two men sitting on steps with three officers standing near them. Officer Frank Welling can be seen putting on gloves and then slamming Will against a wall.
In a criminal complaint filed at the time by Officer Ryan Warnock, police said Will had “balled his hand into a fist” and tried to throw a punch when Officer Welling forced him against the wall to keep from being punched.
Read More
When Beyshaud stands to help, the video shows Officer Warnock using a Taser on him until he is unconscious.
In the criminal complaint, Officer Warnock said Beyshaud had refused a command to sit down and then tried to punch Officer Welling in the back of the head, so he shocked him with the Taser.
At the time, police supervisors said the use of force was justified.
But the El brothers’ lawyer, Todd Hollis, said the force was excessive and part of a pattern of what he called a “culture of brutality” by Pittsburgh police.
Asked why it took two years to file the suit, Mr. Hollis said the brothers, both of whom he said were found guilty of disorderly conduct, were trying to find someone to take their case.
“The boys are adamant that their civil rights were violated,” he said.
The suit names as defendants Lt. Kacsuta, Officer Welling, Officer Warnock and officers Joseph Sobeck, Siara Lawniczak and seven other officers who are either unnamed or partially named.
Pittsburgh officials would not comment and referred questions to the city law department, which did not return a message.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.