The Roman Catholic dioceses of Pittsburgh and Erie on Friday petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to hear their challenge of an Obama-care provision requiring that contraceptives be made available to workers at their charitable agencies.

The petition is one of several similar challenges around the country working their way up to the high court from dioceses, charities and colleges objecting on religious grounds.

The court will have to decide in the coming months whether to hear this or a related case for a precedent-setting ruling.

Many people are already dubbing the issue “Hobby Lobby II,” referring to the 2014 Supreme Court ruling exempting closely held corporations from aspects of the Affordable Care Act to which they have religious objections. Unlike that case involving for-profit businesses, this one would involve religiously affiliated nonprofit groups, which face a different set of rules.

Advertise with us

At issue is the Affordable Care Act’s requirement that most employers provide employees with insurance coverage that includes provision of contraceptives. The requirement doesn’t apply to core religious employers such as churches, but faith-based charities and schools are exempt only if they submit a written objection, after which the insurer directly provides the contraceptive coverage.

The dioceses argue that even by submitting a written objection, this chain of events would make them complicit in a moral evil — facilitating the use of artificial birth control, some of which they argue can cause early-term abortions. Other Catholic entities have made similar arguments in separate suits around the country, while Protestant groups such as Geneva College in Beaver Falls are focusing their objections on providing contraceptives they believe could cause abortions.

The U.S. District Court for Western Pennsylvania sided with the dioceses, but in February, a three-judge panel of the 3rd U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals reversed that ruling, saying the opt-out provision would not make the dioceses complicit in providing birth control.

Faced with an imminent enforcement of the law in April, the dioceses sought and received a temporary stay from Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, who hears such petitions from the 3rd Third Circuit.

Bishop David Zubik of the Pittsburgh diocese said Friday that the principle of the challenge has broader implications than just the Catholic church’s objection to artificial contraception. “Government is telling us what we can and can’t do” as a religious organization, he said. “People don’t see this as the slippery slope.”