Livability.com has put Pittsburgh atop yet another of those “best of” lists that appear on the Internet and derive meaning from criteria shared by 10 places whose relationship otherwise would be a total mystery.
In the Best Downtown category, for instance, we topped Fargo by six paces and Greenville by just three. It’s necessary to use Fargo’s last name — North Dakota — and Greenville’s — South Carolina — because Livability’s focus generally is not on places whose first names suffice. Except when it is.
Pittsburgh, Minneapolis and Indianapolis are the top three Best Downtowns on its list, which was announced Monday.
For the Best Downtowns list, Matt Carmichael, editor of Livability, said a few larger cities came out on top because “it’s easier to have a vibrant downtown in a larger place.”
Livability studies demographic data of cities for qualities such as attractive walking conditions, cultural assets, transportation, planning and sustainable design. It concocts Top 10 lists in a number of categories each month.
“It’s a great acknowledgment of the activity that’s been occurring Downtown over the last 10 years,” Jeremy Waldrup, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, said of the ranking. “The numbers speak for themselves, and we are pleased at how that’s changing the landscape, with more people Downtown on nights and weekends.”
Read More
Pittsburgh’s Downtown population has reached 4,400, a four-fold increase after having just a little more than 1,000 in 2000.
Mr. Carmichael said one thing that sets Livability apart from other ranking sites is its interest in shining the limelight on cities that rarely get the attention that Austin, Portland and Seattle attract. “We know there are great stories to tell in these places.”
Among its “best of” lists are best affordable cities, best beer cities, best places to retire, best places for liberals and best places for centrists.
Mr. Carmichael said Livability has crunched data on about 2,000 cities but has not visited all of them.
“I was in Pittsburgh for a conference on walkability and biking last fall and saw its Downtown firsthand,” he said. “It’s nice to see Pittsburgh turned around. Mayor Peduto was in Chicago last summer and I got to talk to him. It was great to hear about all the things going on and to see the energy there.”
He said he would not recommend that the list prompt a move to the top city on any list, “but if you are looking for a great downtown, there is probably a place for you” in one of the cities on the list. “We understand that the idea of a great downtown and livability means something different to everyone.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.