A Mount Oliver man acquitted of robbing a South Side bank has sued the city of Pittsburgh and the two detectives who charged him, saying the officers displayed “unconscionable abuse” of their authority in arresting him for a crime he didn't commit.

Dale Shaffer, 25, had been accused of a March 2013 robbery of the PNC Bank branch on East Carson Street and a burglary a few days later at the Games N’ At store on Josephine Street.

The burglary case was dismissed, and Mr. Shaffer was acquitted at trial in the bank robbery case earlier this year after the jury deliberated for only 15 minutes, but he had spent nearly a year in jail waiting for the trial because he couldn’t make bond.

Mr. Shaffer’s suit for false arrest, filed Thursday in U.S. District Court, names the city and detectives Nicholas Bobbs and Antonio Ciummo, who based their case on a photo lineup in which he was the only one with shoulder-length curly hair, according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

The case began March 13 when a robber entered the PNC branch and passed the teller a demand note.

Although two male employees caught a glimpse of him, they didn’t get a good look because they didn’t realize a robbery was taking place. The teller was the only one who saw the bandit clearly, saying he was 5 feet 10 and 160 pounds with long, black, curly hair, braces and dark sunglasses.

After police released a photo to the media on March 14, Mr. Shaffer’s estranged mother called them and said he matched the description.

Officers then put his photo in an array to show the bank employees.

The teller couldn’t pick him out, but the two male employees did even though both said they hadn’t gotten a good look at the robber.

Advertise with us

In the suit, Mr. Shaffer said the photo array was “unduly suggestive” because he was the only one of eight subjects with shoulder-length, dark, curly hair that all the witnesses said matched the robber’s.

He also said that at the time of the robbery, he was more than two miles away at a friend’s house, helping him install insulation.

What’s more, he said he never had braces, as the teller said the robber did, but police also showed a surveillance image from the bank robbery to Mr. Shaffer’s parole officer, who said it was him.

The detectives arrested him March 27.

Because he was on probation from a previous conviction for driving under the influence, he was held in the county jail on a detainer and unable to make bond.

Advertise with us

The detectives came to the jail to arrest him again on April 26, this time for the Games N’ At burglary on March 17.

Then the store was burglarized again on June 18, and again the person in the surveillance images looked to be the same as the suspect in the previous burglary and the bank robbery.

Because Mr. Shaffer was in jail when the latest burglary occurred, the Games N’ At case was dismissed, according to the suit.

Mr. Shaffer was acquitted in the bank robbery in February after a one-day trial.

Mr. Shaffer’s suit is asking for damages for emotional distress and lost income for the time he spent in jail.