A long and sprawling probe of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police and the former mayor’s office appeared to draw to a close Monday with the arrest of a civilian payroll accountant charged with stealing from the city.
Tamara L. Davis turned herself in to the Allegheny County district attorney’s office, which took over an investigation of her from the FBI in late August — 10 months after the city’s former police chief, Nate Harper, pleaded guilty to federal crimes.
Ms. Davis, 48, of the Hill District, was arraigned by District Judge Oscar Petite Jr. on felony counts of theft by unlawful taking, theft by deception and forgery, and one misdemeanor count of misapplication of entrusted property.
Following the arrest, the district attorney’s office announced: “With the filing of these charges, our office does not anticipate any other individuals being charged in connection with the handling of these funds.”
That was welcome news to some in city hall.
“I think first and foremost closure means we can move forward,” Councilman Dan Gilman said. “This is a chance for us to look forward to a new era of growth and prosperity without looking backward to a dark spot in our history.”
Read More
Ms. Davis’ attorney, Frank Rapp, accompanied her Monday morning to City Court, where she surrendered.
After her arraignment, Ms. Davis was released on her own recognizance. She walked from the Downtown courthouse to a nearby parking garage, ignoring questions from reporters. Mr. Rapp could not be reached.
Ms. Davis and Harper, her former boss and onetime business partner in a now-defunct private security startup, were subjects of a federal grand jury investigation that ended in August.
That month, the FBI turned over to the DA’s office four CDs of records in connection with the “Grand Jury Investigation of Nathan Harper and Tamara Davis,” court paperwork shows.
By then, Harper had pleaded guilty to four counts of failure to file federal income taxes and one count of conspiracy to divert more than $70,000 in city funds into two off-the-books accounts. One was called “I.P.F.”
The charges against Ms. Davis accuse her of stealing money from I.P.F. Ms. Davis, as second-in-command of the police bureau’s personnel and finance office, had access to the account.
Investigators allege that Ms. Davis stole various amounts totaling $9,165 from the city on five instances between 2009 and 2012.
In some cases, Ms. Davis withdrew cash from the account while depositing checks made out to the bureau, according to an affidavit supporting the criminal charges.
Ms. Davis also forged invoices to obtain a $3,000 check made out to the police bureau, the affidavit said. She was accused of depositing $1,000 of that money into the I.P.F. account and keeping the rest.
Last year, the federal probe of misappropriated city funds came to light as investigators seized materials from police headquarters, Harper was forced to resign, a grand jury heard testimony and Ms. Davis was put on paid leave with three other bureau employees.
In the 21 months since she was placed on leave, Ms. Davis earned more than $75,000. But Mayor Bill Peduto had her status changed Monday to unpaid after the charges were filed.
Two others remain on paid leave — Sandra Ganster, Ms. Davis’ supervisor; and Officer Tonya Montgomery-Ford, who worked at police headquarters.
The three women have earned more than $309,000 combined while they have been on leave. Mr. Peduto would not say whether Ms. Davis will be fired.
“I don’t want to even speculate on that right now. The first step and the first action though is to make sure her leave is no longer being paid by the taxpayers,” he said.
Mr. Peduto said Ms. Ganster and Officer Montgomery-Ford will remain on leave until he is formally contacted by investigators.
Court paperwork offered glimpses of how Ms. Ganster and Officer Montgomery-Ford interacted with Ms. Davis.
Detective Kevin Flanigan wrote that Ms. Davis would tell Ms. Ganster “when money was needed in the I.P.F. [account] and directed Ganster to take checks from Karen Palmer, Accountant, Office of Personnel and Finance.”
The affidavit accuses Ms. Davis of withdrawing $4,000 from I.P.F. under the guise of buying riot shields for the 2009 G-20 summit. But instead of using the money on bureau expenses, Ms. Davis kept it for herself, the affidavit said.
Detective Flanigan also noted a July 2012 instance in which a $3,000 City of Pittsburgh check was made out to “Pittsburgh Bureau of Police C/O Tammy Davis.”
He wrote that Ms. Davis told authorities she gave that money to Lt. Matthew Gauntner, a former mayoral bodyguard, for the D.A.R.E. program.
But the lieutenant told investigators he did not receive that cash and instead got a check from the Mayor’s Youth Council for the program, the affidavit said.
Investigators showed Lt. Gauntner two invoices submitted under his name to acquire the check; he said that he has never prepared an invoice, according to the affidavit.
Detective Flanigan wrote that he suspects Ms. Davis submitted the invoices and kept a portion of the money for herself.
The detective also wrote that Officer Montgomery-Ford, who ran a business called D&T Enterprises, submitted an invoice to Ms. Davis for providing hundreds of children’s backpacks to the bureau’s youth program. A check to pay for the bags was cut from the I.P.F. account.
Ms. Davis told Officer Montgomery-Ford that the money was paid from the wrong account and asked her to “reissue an invoice to be paid out of a proper account,” the detective wrote.
In response, Officer Montgomery-Ford wrote an invoice for $1,976.20 for the backpacks, the affidavit said, and the city cut a check for that amount.
“When Ford asked how to reimburse the money already received, [Ms. Davis] requested it to be made in cash,” the affidavit said.
Officer Montgomery-Ford wrote a $2,000 check, cashed it and gave it to Ms. Davis, who used it on herself, according to the affidavit.
Officer Montgomery-Ford has a pending federal suit against the city demanding her return to work and payment for lost overtime.
Her attorney, Samuel Cordes, said Monday that she testified before the federal grand jury with immunity, though he did not have details about the arrangement.
Formal immunity would mean that nothing she said before the grand jury could be used against her in any proceeding.
Ms. Ganster also testified before the grand jury with limited immunity, according to her attorney.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.