Eleven months ago, the Penguins presented their plans to redevelop the former Civic Arena site to the Hill District community only to be beaten back by residents upset about elements of it. They tried again Monday evening — with much the same result.
Packing Kaufmann Center in the Hill, some residents continued to attack the levels of affordable housing budgeted for the arena site, while others worried that the development that takes place there would cause rents to rise elsewhere in the neighborhood and force them to relocate.
The concerns came even though the team reached a comprehensive agreement with Hill and Pittsburgh and Allegheny County leaders last month that addressed issues such as affordable housing and participation by minority- and women-owned businesses and paved the way for the development to proceed.
Monday’s meeting was not to address such issues but to discuss the preliminary land development plan the Penguins have submitted to the city planning department, casting their vision to redevelop the 28-acre lower Hill site with apartments, townhouses, sidewalk cafes, retail and plazas. The team won the rights to develop the site as part of the 2007 deal to build the Consol Energy Center.
But such distinctions did not deter those who attended Monday night. Some residents complained that the 20 percent affordable housing level called for in the agreement was not high enough — even though Travis Williams, the Penguins’ chief operating officer, said the deal could mean that some of the nearly 1,200 units to be built could rent for as low as $600.
“There’s families here that could be dislocated as part of this thing,” said one Hill resident. “They can’t afford $600.”
Read More
Furthermore, Carl Redwood, head of the Hill District Consensus Group, argued that the terms negotiated by the Penguins and community and political leaders needed to be incorporated into the preliminary land development plan that is to be approved by the city.
He also questioned whether the lower rent rates would stay in effect for only a few years, but Mr. Williams said that was not the case. While the rate, based on current financing, can’t go beyond 10 years, it could be extended, he said.
In addition to the nearly 1,200 residential units, the proposed development is expected to include 250,000 square feet of commercial and entertainment space; 632,000 square feet of office space; and a 150-room hotel. The Penguins estimate that total investment could exceed $400 million and may top half a billion dollars.
Besides concerns about affordable housing, residents like Goldette Shields expressed fear that the development could end up increasing values throughout the neighborhood and “raise rents to slowly force us out.” Mr. Williams said that is not the intent, noting that part of the tax revenue generated by the development will be used in other parts of the Hill for redevelopment purposes.
Marimba Milliones, president and CEO of the Hill Community Development Corp., told residents that while issues like affordable housing and minority hiring were important, so was the preliminary land development plan, which she described as the “new law” for the land.
The plan will serve as the blueprint for the development over the next decade. The team also is seeking to change zoning to a specially planned district. Both must be approved by the city planning commission. City council also must approve the zoning change.
Hill residents did get some good news during Monday’s meeting. Mr. Williams said the team and the city have agreed to fund half of the estimated $1.8 million cost for the long-delayed Curtain Call art project that was supposed to be part of the Consol Energy Center development. The team hopes to secure the rest of the funding from local foundations by next spring to make the project a reality.
The team also plans to hold four more public meetings on the preliminary land development plan, which will go before the planning commission for a briefing next month. Details relating to it can be found at www.civicarenaredevelopment.com. The next public meeting will be Oct. 13 from 11:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. at the Power Center at Duquesne University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.