Pittsburgh's mayor's office has been required since 2006 to produce an annual report showing at least the gender, age and ZIP code of members appointed to city boards, authorities and commissions.

Six reports should be part of the public record, but none exist.

Each report would have been the responsibility of Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, who took office eight months after the passage of the Fair Representation law. The law outlines efforts toward diversity and transparency in board appointments.

The theory was that by holding officials accountable for appointments and giving the public a way to easily apply for vacancies, appointees would reflect the city's diversity.

Advertise with us

PG graphic: Races that comprise Pittsburgh boards versus the population

(Click image for larger version)

The 2006 city law followed a Heinz School of Public Policy study that found 34 percent of the 129 city appointees were women while 51 percent of the city's working-age population were women.

Councilman Bill Peduto, the District 8 Democrat who introduced the ordinance, was concerned that the diversity reports do not exist.

"These are public boards making decisions using public dollars, and that information should be available at your fingertips," said Mr. Peduto, who is expected to run for mayor next year.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ravenstahl, a former councilman, was a co-sponsor of the ordinance. However, his administration has failed to produce a single report to city council about the makeup of boards.

"I don't think because there has been no formal submission to city council that it is in any way hampering our ability to have diversity or transparency," said Mr. Ravenstahl, a Democrat. "The information is available, and people can get it."

It took 2 1/2 months before the mayor's office provided any information to PublicSource.

The Right-to-Know officer told PublicSource: "No such records exist."

Members of the mayor's staff said the data were collected, but the reports had not been compiled.

Advertise with us

Gabriel Mazefsky, the mayor's policy manager, eventually provided a breakdown of the race and gender of current appointees for all 209 appointments Mr. Ravenstahl has made since taking office in September 2006.

The recent numbers show that 31 more women are on boards now than in late 2005. However, women still make up 38 percent of sitting members, while they account for 52 percent of the city's population in the 2010 census, the only comparison available.

Blacks make up 24 percent of current board members, while the city's population is 26 percent black, census figures show.

Still, the information is incomplete because the city could not provide annual snapshots of its board members' demographics. In addition, the data did not include age or ZIP code, as required by the law.

Mr. Ravenstahl said he would check into the reason the diversity reports have not been made.

Advertise with us

"We'll take a look at that ordinance," he said. "I can't speak to specifically why it hasn't been done."

Dozens of organizations lobbied for the ordinance at the city and Allegheny County levels, urging officials to make appointments that represent the diversity of Pittsburgh and county populations.

Allegheny County follows a law similar to the city's but does not have a mandate to produce a public report each year. County officials provided the breakdowns of board appointees since 2003 to PublicSource in a little more than a week.

Heather Arnet, executive director of the Women and Girls Foundation, said she is dismayed by the lack of reporting by the mayor.

"Part of why we worked so hard to ensure there would be a report-out component to the process was so that there would be long-term transparency and accountability," Ms. Arnet said.

Advertise with us

"There's been improvement" of blacks sitting on city boards since the ordinance passed, said Tim Stevens, chairman of the Black Political Empowerment Project, a city advocacy group. However, he said, their stake could be greater.

"But if part of the commitment is ignored, the results will never be at a level it could be," he said. "That's a sad comment on the commitment."

Joanna Doven, the mayor's spokeswoman, said the mayor's commitment to diversity shows in his appointments, hiring and programs.

Ms. Doven said the city has seen a 5 percent increase in blacks in management and senior leadership positions since Mr. Ravenstahl took office.

The diversity report may have been overlooked, Ms. Doven said, but the mayor has not forgotten the spirit of the ordinance.

Advertise with us

"So much stuff gets passed by city council on a daily basis, sometimes things can get lost in the shuffle," she said. "The important thing is, are we committed to diversity? Yes."

Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak said it is the responsibility of the mayor and his staff to enforce the laws on the books.

Ms. Rudiak, a Democrat representing District 4, said she plans to follow up on the reporting issue with the mayor's office and the city controller.

"I think this just seems like a fundamental baseline issue."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.