State Sen. Jane Orie had an answer for everything.
During three hours of cross-examination Tuesday, she held her own as Assistant District Attorney Lawrence Claus bombarded her with documents, questions and accusations.
Although the McCandless Republican kept her composure throughout, there were moments when both sides got heated -- including a time when Ms. Orie raised her voice and pointed at the prosecutor.
Mr. Claus had just asked the senator if she removed political items from her North Hills district office or asked former chief of staff, Jamie Pavlot, to do so.
"I have never, ever directed her to take anything out of her office, and I was told there was nothing in her office," Ms. Orie said, her voice raised.
Ms. Orie is charged with theft of services, ethics violations and conspiracy for allegedly using her legislative staff and resources to run campaigns for herself and her sister, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin. The senator also is charged with perjury and forgery, stemming from evidence and testimony she provided during a first trial in the case last year, that ended in a mistrial.
Ms. Orie will return to the stand on cross-examination this morning. The case began three weeks ago.
Although both the senator and Mr. Claus were quite civil with each other -- saying thank you and apologizing if one spoke over the other -- the testimony was marked by a number of tense exchanges.
In one that was particularly brisk, Mr. Claus accused Ms. Orie of adding handwritten notes to a document provided to her by the prosecution in discovery.
"That is totally untrue," she answered. "I did not get your discovery until way after this was scanned, and I take great offense to that."
The senator and the prosecutor had another dispute regarding a letter written by the senator to local nuns on behalf of her sister then-Judge Melvin, who was running in 2009 for state Supreme Court. Ms. Orie testified that the letter was to be sent on her own Pro-Life Caucus letterhead, but that Ms. Pavlot put it on letterhead from her sister's campaign.
"I never saw it. I never signed it," Ms. Orie said of the letter that went out.
Earlier in the day, on direct examination by defense attorney William Costopoulos, Ms. Orie admitted that at least three documents containing Ms. Pavlot's signature were forged. But Ms. Orie denied having anything to do with their creation.
Last week, an analyst with the U.S. Secret Service testified that the signatures were all one and the same and that the original signature used as the model wasn't created until 2010 -- even though it was used on a mileage letter supposedly created in 2006 by Ms. Pavlot.
Placing the documents on the projection screen, Mr. Costopoulos asked: "Did you have anything to do with placing that signature on that document?"
"Absolutely not," Ms. Orie answered.
The senator also told the jury that the forged mileage document contained the wrong letterhead and listed her office at the wrong location.
On cross-examination, Mr. Claus repeatedly asked Ms. Orie how she would have known to write a handwritten directive to Ms. Pavlot on the mileage document if it hadn't been signed by her at the time.
"I have no recall of any signature being on this memo when it was given to me," the senator answered.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.