About 5,400 Allegheny County property owners will find out in the next few days how successful they were in initial appeals of their new assessments.

They are among the 10 percent of all property owners who have filed informal challenges to their new real estate values. They are making their requests for changes to hearing officers who, under a court order, make recommendations to the independent county Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review.

The board's first batch of 5,400 decisions will be mailed out shortly, according to Michael Suley, manager of the county's Office of Property Assessment.

"The assessment is complete," Wesley Graham, the county's acting chief assessment officer, told the judge overseeing real estate revaluation. "The last of the mailings went out."

Advertise with us

While Tuesday's session before Common Pleas Court Senior Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr. ends the court's role in forcing the county to replace its base-year system with one based on market values for real estate, it does not finish the reassessment controversy.

Mr. Graham reported that the owners of 58,481 properties had requested informal hearings on their new values by the March 18 deadline. That number represents about 10.5 percent of the 550,000 taxable parcels in the county. Another 30,000 properties are tax-exempt.

Only 10,000 of those informal sessions have been heard thus far.

More than 21,000 property owners have requested formal hearings on their new real estate values. Owners of homes and commercial properties have until April 2 to file formal appeals. Formal challenges to date are equal to about 4 percent of all taxable properties.

After the state Supreme Court ordered county officials in 2009 to carry out the $11 million reassessment, elected officials, including county Executive Rich Fitzgerald and members of county council, continued to oppose the project. They argue that Allegheny County has been singled out for reassessment while other counties continue to use much older data to value real estate. Mr. Fitzgerald and council members have been holding town meetings to advise residents on how to appeal their new assessments.

Advertise with us

Even as the court's direct role in overseeing reassessment ends, several other issues remain.

Judge Wettick turned down a request from lawyer Patrick Clair, whose firm represents several school districts, for an extension beyond the April 2 deadline for making formal appeals of new values. Some of his clients -- school districts in the county's northern and western suburbs -- only learned of reassessments within their districts on March 9, he said. That date gives school officials less than a month to decide if any of the new values are too low, he said.

While the judge rejected his request to extend the appeals deadline, taxing bodies and property owners still will have additional time in some cases to lodge formal appeals.

In his final order on reassessment, Judge Wettick said he would include a provision giving property owners and governments 30 days to formally challenge changes -- or lack of change -- in assessed values resulting from informal appeals.

With informal appeals likely to take several more months to complete, the outcomes from some of those initial challenges may not be known until late summer. Taxing bodies and taxpayers then would have an additional 30 days after those values are released to make formal appeals.

Advertise with us

Both base-year and new assessment numbers still provide separate values for land and buildings on each parcel. Judge Wettick asked why property values were divided into two parts since Pittsburgh no longer taxes land at a different rate than improvements. Clairton, Duquesne and McKeesport, however, continue to levy different millage rates for land and buildings, county Manager Jim Flynn said.

Separate land values were "really confusing people" and many appeared to "make no sense," Judge Wettick told Mr. Graham.

Mr. Graham said land values were calculated in two basic ways. First, assessors looked at recent sales of similar properties, he said. Second, the land value was the amount that remained after the replacement value of structures on the property was reduced by depreciation.

He said it should not be surprising that the value of land -- which is of finite supply -- should have risen faster since 2002 than the value of buildings.

The new assessment numbers will not be used to calculate property taxes until 2013. That delay will give property owners time to challenge new values and taxing bodies time to adjust their millage rates downward to reflect increases in total assessments.