Allegheny County Council has replaced two key employees, but the method used to hire the new staff members has upset two councilmen.

Walter Szymanski was selected from among 20 applicants to become council's budget director. Celeste Stevens was picked to become council's executive secretary, responsible for purchasing and payroll, among other duties.

Council's five-member executive committee made the final decision to hire Mr. Szymanski and Ms. Stevens, a move that Councilman Michael Finnerty, D-Scott, said contradicted "past practices" for the county's governing body.

Council committees make recommendations, Mr. Finnerty said. Final action on ordinances, resolutions and staff hiring all should be made by the full 15-member council.

Advertise with us

Council Vice President Nick Futules, D-Oakmont, who chairs the executive committee, disagreed. He sought a legal opinion from council solicitor John Cambest, who advised him that the executive committee has the power to hire.

It would be inappropriate, in any case, to discuss such matters before full council because they involve personnel issues, Mr. Futules said.

That explanation did not satisfy Councilman James Ellenbogen, D-Banksville. "I don't know anything about who these people are," he said of the new hires. He described the executive committee's action as "power politics ... it may be legally right, but morally it is not right."

As they debated the issue during Tuesday's council meeting, Mr. Finnerty and Mr. Futules became angrier, with both sometimes seeking to speak at the same time. "You shut up," Mr. Finnerty said at one point to Mr. Futules. "You don't have the floor."

"Let's keep this civil," council President Charles Martoni said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Futules said he had invited all members of council to sit in on the interviews with candidates for the two jobs. "I sought an opinion from the solicitor, and I thought I was doing my job as committee chairman," he said. "I am sorry if I offended anyone."

Councilman Vince Gastgeb, a member of the Executive Committee, defended the process. Interviewing and hiring candidates took 45 days, the Bethel Park Republican said. That period allowed adequate time for council members to have input, he said, making the committee's decision to hire both legally and morally correct.

Mr. Finnerty said he had no objections to the people selected for the jobs. "I'd gladly have voted for them ... but the matter should have been brought before full council," he said.

Mr. Szymanski succeeds Jennifer Liptak, who resigned to become county Executive Rich Fitzgerald's chief of staff. His annual salary was set at $70,000. He works as finance manager for District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr. His starting date is next Monday.

Ms. Stevens has been employed in a similar capacity at the county's Shuman Juvenile Detention Center. Her salary was set at $35,000. She follows Sonya Dietz, who moved across the hall in the county courthouse last month to become executive secretary and office manager for Mr. Fitzgerald. Ms. Stevens is to start her new job today.

Council's budget allows for a staff of eight, but in recent years it has operated with six full-timers. In addition to the two slots that now have been filled, the positions of council clerk and legislative assistant have been vacant for more than two years.