Republicans will display their maps, and Democrats their grievances today at a hearing before the panel charged with drawing the state's legislative landscape for the next decade.

Members of the Legislative Reapportionment Commission's Republican majority have defended their preliminary plan, adopted in a 3-2 party line vote, as the logical product of the state's demographic shifts over the decade since the current district lines were drawn in 2001. Some Democrats have assailed the blueprint as a calculated effort to lock in GOP control of the state House and Senate.

"The Allegheny County map very much reflects the partisan approach that's been taken statewide," said Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill. "It's a Republican majority protection plan."

Rep. Mike Turzai, the House majority leader and one of the GOP commission members, rejected the Democratic critique.

Advertise with us

"If you look at the facts, 27 out of the 28 districts held by Democrats in the southwest lost population. ... It was clear that there needed to be at least two seats from the southwest lost."

He argued that the two seats shifted from the region will move to Democratic areas in Allentown and Chester County, rather than to naturally Republican areas. Mr. Turzai also noted that one current GOP seat from the northwestern part of the state had been shifted to the east.

"We gave the Democrats some deference on population although arguably all three [House] seats [moved from the state's west to the east] should have been Democratic," he contended.

In Allegheny County, the preliminary plan eliminates one state Senate seat and two House seats. State Sen. Jim Brewster's Mon Valley seat was moved to the eastern half of the Poconos. His McKeesport home is now in the proposed district represented by Sen. Tim Solobay, D-Washington County. Mr. Brewster could run for that seat, now dominated by Washington County communities, but its reconfigured geography would appear to favor his neighbor, Mr. Solobay.

The House template eliminates the Pittsburgh seat now held by Rep. Chelsa Wagner, who is about to move to a new office, succeeding Mark Patrick Flaherty as the county controller. On the western edge of the county, the seat held by Rep. Nick Kotik, D-Coraopolis, has been merged with the currently adjoining district of Rep. Jesse White, D-Washington County.

Advertise with us

In the first version of the proposal, circulated last month, it appeared that two other pairs of Democratic incumbents in the county would face the prospect of running against one another. Reps. Matt Smith, D-Mt. Lebanon, and Dan Deasy, who represents neighborhoods in Pittsburgh's West End and several adjoining suburbs, were lumped in one new seat while Reps. Dom Costa, D-Morningside, and Adam Ravenstahl, D-North Side, were paired in another new seat. But the commission said those two combinations had been oversights.

On Wednesday, it issued official tweaks to the preliminary map that restored each of the lawmakers to their own altered districts.

For Mr. Ravenstahl, the brother of Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, the change might be a case of good news and bad news. The good news is that he does not have to face Mr. Costa in a primary. The bad is that his new district, the 20th, now contains only a sliver of his North Side political base. Instead the seat is dominated by suburban communities including Ross and a handful of boroughs along the Ohio River. The district retains a Democratic registration majority, but those communities have trended Republican in recent statewide and national elections, meaning that the new district could make the relatively new lawmaker vulnerable to either a primary or general election challenge.

Mr. Kotik, who has complained strenuously about the proposal, said he hadn't made up his mind on whether to try to capture a new district dominated by unfamiliar constituents. He acknowledged that retirement is among his options but said that he still hadn't reached a decision.

"Mr. White and I are both friends; we have to sit down and talk about it," he said. "The last thing I want to have is a primary challenge against a colleague. We'll look for some kind of common ground."

Advertise with us

He and other politicians weighing the implications and opportunities of the new map have a limited time to make their decisions. Because 2012 is a presidential election year, the state's primary is early, falling in April rather than the May date of non-presidential years. That means candidates face a Feb. 14 deadline to submit nominating petitions for whatever office they choose to seek.

Today's hearing in Harrisburg will concentrate on comments on the new districts for the western part of the state. A subsequent hearing on Nov. 23 will focus on new seats in the east. The Democratic critics of the proposal have very limited leverage to alter it. Under the state Constitution, legislative redistricting, as opposed to congressional redistricting, is handled by a five-member panel. Four seats go to the Republican and Democratic leaders of the state House and Senate. When those four could not agree to a fifth member, the GOP-dominated state Supreme Court chose former Superior Court Judge Stephen J. McEwen Jr., a respected jurist, but a former GOP prosecutor in Delaware County.

Critics of the map could consider legal challenges to its shape, a possibility raised by state Sen. Jay Costa, a panel member, when the map was unveiled last month. But courts, while vigilant against violations of minority rights and wide disparities in district sizes, have been reluctant to overturn legislative and congressional redistricting efforts simply because they confer a partisan advantage on one party or another.

Mr. Frankel, the House Democratic caucus chair, noted that the 3-2, party line vote on the preliminary plan contrasted with a 5-0 vote approving the last legislative map a decade ago. He argued that the split highlighted the partisan cast of this proposal. The 2001 plan was controversial from a different perspective, however, as some Democrats complained that their leadership had crafted a deal with Republicans to purge dissident votes from the Democratic House caucus. Accommodating a similar shift of population from the west to the east, the 2001 map eliminated the seats of former Reps. David Mayernik, D-Ross, and Ralph Kaiser, D-Brentwood, two incumbents with maverick voting records in the assessments of Rep. Bill DeWeese, then the Democratic leader of the House and former Rep. Mike Veon, his chief lieutenant.

"When they decided to move two seats out of Western Pennsylvania then, DeWeese ad Veon moved their enemies out so there wasn't as much carping,'' said Terry Madonna, a Franklin & Marshall College political scientist.

Advertise with us

Of the current proposal, and the demographic shifts underlying it, the longtime observer of state politics said, "There was no question that seats had to move from the west to the east.''

Pointing to the shift of the Brewster seat from the Mon Valley to Monroe County, he said, "They took the one with the least seniority; they didn't go after senior members of the caucus ... all in all, I don't see tremendous unfairness here.'"