An Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge on Friday denied several motions made earlier this week by state Sen. Jane Orie.
Defense attorney William Costopoulos asked that Ms. Orie's Oct. 3 trial date be continued. He also asked Judge Jeffrey A. Manning to join the trials of his client's former case against her with the newly filed charges brought last month alleging forgery and perjury.
Judge Manning denied both requests without any explanation.
In addition, Ms. Orie asked that the court reconsider allowing jurors from her 40th Senatorial District into the jury pool. That, too, was denied.
A request to have the jury panel sequestered, the court said, will be considered at jury selection.
Ms. Orie originally went on trial for charges including theft of services and conspiracy in February. She and her sister, Janine Orie, were accused of using the senator's legislative staff and resources to campaign on behalf of another sister, now Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin.
The case ended in a mistrial in March on the second day of deliberations. On March 3, prosecutors went to Judge Manning alleging that the defense presented fraudulent documents to the court.
The judge declared a mistrial. Since then, the defense has filed a number of appeals, arguing that Jane Orie cannot be retried on the charges because double jeopardy applies.
However, Judge Manning and the state Superior Court disagree, finding that the double jeopardy claim is frivolous.
Both courts found that the defense was responsible for the admission of the forged documents and therefore should not benefit by not having a retrial.
Mr. Costopoulos on Thursday asked the state Supreme Court to hear the appeal.
Last month, the Allegheny County district attorney's office filed new charges of perjury and forgery against Ms. Orie in relation to her testimony at trial and the forged documents.
A preliminary hearing on that case is scheduled for the end of the month.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.