The political career of former Pittsburgh City Council president and mayoral thorn-in-the-side Doug Shields has suffered a knockout.
After a rather blistering campaign, Shadyside attorney Hugh McGough won the Democratic nomination for an open district judge seat in the city's East End, beating Mr. Shields and attorneys Dan Butler and Joe Weinroth. Mr. McGough won the Republican nomination too, meaning there will be no rematch Nov. 8.
This curious campaign gained immediate prominence when Mr. Shields, 57, a longtime council aide to late Mayor Bob O'Connor, decided to step down from council after two terms to go for the judicial position. The race was then cast as one between a political veteran without a legal degree against three experienced lawyers.
"It's really, really thrilling for me," Mr. McGough said from his campaign party in Shadyside.
Mr. McGough said the win grew out of "persistence and building a network of supporters who watched me over the last two or three election cycles, and were pleased with the type of law practice I developed, and confident I was prepared to handle these new responsibilities."
The race grew nasty in its final days -- with supporters of Mr. McGough tangling with Mr. Shields in the newspaper letters to the editor section -- which is all the more interesting because it almost didn't happen. The state's judicial system faces a budget crunch just like every other branch of Pennsylvania government, and when current District Judge Nathan Firestone reached mandatory retirement age, the seat was ripe for extinction. About 50 magisterial district seats are to be cut statewide this year.
But local district judges pleaded with judicial leaders to keep the seat, largely to help the revolving oversight of cases at City Court, Downtown, and the seat was saved.
Mr. McGough, 55, of Shadyside, is an attorney in private practice and court-appointed federal mediator whose firm represents the Citizen Police Review Board. He was an assistant solicitor for city government for nine years and has served on the Pittsburgh AIDS Task Force and other charities. He ran unsuccessfully for the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court bench in 2009.
Mr. Shields argued that despite his lack of a legal pedigree his political experience would make him a skilled mediator on the bench. Besides, legal degrees are not necessary to be a district judge -- non-lawyers are merely required to complete a training course offered by the state's Minor Judiciary Education Board -- and two of his ex-council colleagues, Gene Ricciardi and Jim Motznik, successfully ran for district judge positions.
Mr. Butler, 59, of Squirrel Hill, is a federally funded attorney representing disadvantaged parents. He was a magistrate in Pittsburgh Municipal Court for 11 years back when mayors Sophie Masloff and Tom Murphy were still in charge of appointments. He came in second on the Republican side of the race.
Mr. Shields, of Squirrel Hill, worked for law firms for nine years as a litigation paralegal before starting work as then-Councilman Bob O'Connor's chief of staff in 1992. He took over the council seat in 2003. He became a vocal critic of the Ravenstahl administration, taking on the mayor on issues such as lost and stolen guns, electronic billboards and a city ban on Marcellus Shale drilling.
Mr. Weinroth, 52, of Squirrel Hill, is a former Republican candidate for mayor in 2005 and the Common Pleas bench in 2007. He has been a lawyer for 28 years.
The six-year terms pay a base annual salary of $82,303. The seat oversees Park Place, Point Breeze, Regent Square, Shadyside, Squirrel Hill and Swisshelm Park.
Allegheny County election results can be found at http://www.alleghenycounty.us/elect/201105pri/results.aspx. Click on "summary report."
State election results can be found at http://www.electionreturns.state.pa.us/.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.