The Pennsylvania Senate Republican caucus has been ordered to respond to a lawsuit over its decision to cancel a contract with a company that made constituent calls and provided voter-registration data.

Commonwealth Court last week gave the caucus a month to file an answer to the lawsuit by Easton-based Precision Marketing Inc. that seeks $1.2 million for terminating the deal early.

The five-judge opinion issued on Wednesday said the caucus argued that it was "part and parcel of the General Assembly" but that such claims need to be raised by filing a new matter with the court. The judges ruled against the caucus in its attempt to have the case thrown out, saying it was unclear from the face of the complaint whether the caucus is entitled to sovereign immunity protection.

The dispute concerns a July 2009 cancellation letter to Precision president Thomas E. Severson from the two top-ranking Senate Republicans, President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati of Jefferson County and Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi of Delaware County.

Advertise with us

Senate GOP lawyer Drew Crompton said the computer consulting contract was ended because Mr. Severson was charged with filing fraudulent campaign expense reports and submitting deceptive invoices. He said the data from Precision went beyond voter registration information.

Mr. Severson pleaded guilty last year to 12 counts of tampering with public records and two other offenses, in a case unrelated to the Senate Republican work.