A Secret Service forgery analysis released to the media last week has sent the Allegheny County District Attorney's office and lawyers for state Sen. Jane Orie and her sister into a tizzy, each side pointing fingers at the other for the leak.
Ms. Orie, a McCandless Republican, and her sister, Janine Orie, face a retrial in October on corruption charges, accused of using public resources and employees in campaigns for the senator and a third sister, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin. Justice Melvin has not been charged.
Their first trial began in February, but Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning declared a mistrial after prosecutors raised concerns that documents entered by the defense had been doctored.
Numerous documents were released to Secret Service investigators, who analyzed the inks used in handwritten notes by Ms. Orie. Their report, obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Friday, said the analysis was inconclusive.
In separate court filings Monday, lawyers for both sisters accused the district attorney's office of releasing the report to KDKA-TV. In a supplement to an appeal to the state Supreme Court, Jane Orie's lawyer further claimed that the report cleared his client of court fraud.
"The Secret Service Report forensically exonerates Senator Orie from having fabricated or tampered with the volumes of defense exhibits," William Costopoulos wrote.
Mr. Costopolous has appealed to the higher court to bar the sisters' retrial, arguing that it would constitute double jeopardy. He contended that the Secret Service report corroborates his case that the trial court "lacked manifest necessity to declare a mistrial."
In a news release last week, district attorney spokesman Michael Manko said the report had been disseminated by the defendant.
"It is important to note that the report has to be analyzed in conjunction with several other pieces of evidence which are not in the defendant's possession," Mr. Manko wrote. "Failure to do so" could lead to uninformed or misleading conclusions, he said.
A lawyer for Janine Orie used Mr. Manko's statement as the basis for a motion Monday, asking Judge Manning to compel the state to release the "other pieces of evidence" Mr. Manko mentioned.
"The report was not provided by the Commonwealth to defense counsel until May 6, 2011, after the report itself and a skewed version of its meaning were leaked to a local newscaster, Martin Griffin of KDKA, apparently either by the Secret Service or the Commonwealth," James DePasquale wrote in the motion.
There is a court-imposed gag order in the case. Mr. Manko wrote in his release that because the Secret Service report "is part of the evidence in an additional and separate prosecution," it was appropriate for him to comment.
The Secret Service analysis showed that 18 inks used by Ms. Orie in handwritten notes were commercially available at the time she had made them, according to the report. Had those inks not been available then, it would have proved she had forged the documents, bolstering the prosecution's case. But the report does not eliminate that possibility, either.
"No conclusion could be made regarding the authenticity of any of the inked documents," the report stated.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.