Pittsburgh City Councilman Ricky Burgess said he's spent three years fighting for low- and moderate-income residents, but his opponents say he's been arrogant, out of touch and unable to lift troubled District 9 neighborhoods.

Squaring off for the Democratic nomination in the May 17 primary are Mr. Burgess, a North Point Breeze resident seeking his second term; Phyllis Copeland-Mitchell, a social worker who lives in Lincoln-Lemington; and Lucille Prater-Holliday, a Homewood resident and community activist. All are 54 years old.

Mr. Burgess, who's also an associate professor with a full-time teaching load at Community College of Allegheny County and senior pastor of Nazarene Baptist Church in Homewood, pushed through legislation designed to funnel more federal grant money to the poorest city neighborhoods. He co-authored a law that he said is designed to bring efficiency, transparency and public input to the city's capital budget process.

He is a founder of a city program targeting gang homicides and wants to boost former convicts' employment chances by having a question about criminal history removed from the city's job application.

Advertise with us

After Jordan Miles' bloody confrontation with three undercover officers on a Homewood street last year, he pushed through police-accountability legislation, including one bill mandating that video and audio equipment be installed in most police cars. Additional accountability legislation is pending.

"Our children shouldn't live in fear of the police," Mr. Burgess said last week in a controversial campaign mailer that highlighted some of the police accountability bills and quoted Terez Miles, Mr. Miles' mother, as supporting his efforts. The mailer hit constituents' homes just as the U.S. Justice Department announced that the officers wouldn't be charged with violating Mr. Miles' civil rights.

The mailer referred to some of the bills as the "Jordan Miles Public Safety Reform Agenda." While that was the original title, Mr. Burgess dropped Mr. Miles' name from the legislation last summer after colleagues complained that investigations of the confrontation were still under way and that naming legislation for him was premature.

Asked whether the mailer promoted police-neighborhood relations, Mr. Burgess said, "I believe it is a part of that conversation, yes." But police were furious.

"It is frustrating and upsetting to know that one of our key political figures in the city has chosen to point a finger at the police as being the problem rather than attempting to work together to solve the many issues that plague the eastern neighborhoods of the city," said Lt. Jason Lando of Zone 5, which covers Homewood. "With all the shootings and robberies and burglaries that occur in Mr. Burgess' district, it is shocking to know that the platform he chooses to run on is that of police brutality."

Advertise with us

Police Chief Nathan Harper called the campaign literature "in very poor taste and an insult" to police.

The councilman's opponents aren't happy with him, either.

Ms. Prater-Holliday said conditions in some parts of the district "are getting worse." Mr. Burgess is "unresponsive to his constituents. He's not visible in the district. ... He's very arrogant," she said.

As president of the community group Action United, Ms. Prater-Holliday said she's advocated for health care, clean air and water and worker rights. In addition, she said, she's been a single mom, experienced poverty and lived in foster care and on welfare.

"I've lived the life of so many people in District 9," she said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Prater-Holliday, who's endorsed by the Allegheny County Labor Council, said she wants to establish neighborhood councils in each part of the district and make sure residents have a voice in how to turn around their neighborhoods. She also wants to start green-training programs at Community College of Allegheny County's Homewood-Brushton Center and encourage families to rehabilitate Homewood's housing stock.

"I feel I need to step up and be the leader it's going to take to revitalize this district," she said.

Ms. Copeland-Mitchell, who's endorsed by Allegheny County Democratic Committee, also criticized Mr. Burgess' attitude.

"When you approach him about situations in the community, he doesn't seem really concerned. ... I plan to be a visible and approachable council person," she said, claiming Mr. Burgess has been visible only during his campaign.

Ms. Copeland-Mitchell wouldn't release all details of her plans for the district, but said she envisions a phased turnaround, with comprehensive cleanup efforts and public-safety gains preceding business development efforts. She said she'd like to see officers walking beats in district neighborhoods.

She also promised to be inclusive. "I will not make decisions for the community unless someone from the community is at the table," she said.