In a 1965 Seneca Valley High School yearbook picture, 15-year-old freshman Debra Ridgley sports a checkered dress and bob haircut and is flashing a smile.

The innocence of that moment now seems lost forever. Today the 56-year-old grandmother sits in a Panamanian jail, charged in the death last month of another Western Pennsylvania native, Toni Grossi Abrams, 57, from whom she rented an apartment.

Panama City police have accused Ms. Ridgley and two Colombians of murdering Ms. Abrams. Her corpse was stuffed into a suitcase, and whatever wouldn't fit was lopped off. Her remains were dumped in a desolate part of the city and set afire.

"This was a cold-blooded attack," said Seth Redlich, 42, a cousin of Ms. Abrams' late husband who does business in Panama. "There can't be any possible explanation or reason for committing such a crime against anyone, much less my beautiful cousin."

Advertise with us

Ms. Ridgley's attorney, Donatilo Ballesteros, says his client is innocent. In a recent interview, he said that according to Ms. Ridgley, a drunken and nearly hysterical Ms. Abrams attacked her with a knife for no apparent reason, prompting one of the Colombian men to intervene. He said Ms. Ridgley ran out of the room and did not even know Ms. Abrams was dead until the next day.

"She is not an accomplice; she had nothing to do with the murder. She is a victim," Mr. Ballesteros said.

Both Colombians remain at large. Ms. Ridgley's stay in custody appears indefinite. The district attorney's office in Panama will say only that the investigation is continuing.

Panamanian authorities say evidence indicates Ms. Ridgley was involved in the crime. Friends and family of Ms. Ridgley say that despite her faults, including a struggle for years with alcohol, she is a warm, compassionate person incapable of murder.

"I honestly couldn't find a bad thing to say about her," said Debby Gross, of Harmony Township, Beaver County, a friend of Ms. Ridgley and her boyfriend, Gary Krupowicz, for 25 years. "I just can't believe this whole thing. Hopefully, the truth will come out."

Advertise with us

Ms. Ridgley's son, Joe Ridgley, and daughter, Stacy Rader, insist their mother is being framed by the two Colombians.

Mr. Ridgley has said one of the men, Didier "Andres" Osorio Garcia, 24, admitted to him that he killed Ms. Abrams, a Staten Island, N.Y., socialite, and asked for several hundred dollars to flee Panama.

"The guy was calling him up every day for two or three days. He wanted some money; he wanted to get out of the country. He said, 'I can't turn myself in because I'm wanted in Colombia and if they catch me and put me in jail I'm never going to get out,' " said Mr. Ridgley's father, Walter George Barcheski, Ms. Ridgley's second husband. "And then all of a sudden he didn't call no more."

"Andres is the key to the whole puzzle," said Mr. Ridgley, 39, a school security officer from Warren, Ohio. "They need to find him."

The second Colombian, Camilo Castro, 40, was detained by Costa Rican authorities April 17 for entering the country illegally. They deported him to Colombia, where he was released despite a bulletin from Panamanian police to Interpol alerting law enforcement that he was wanted, said Rafael Ruiz, spokesman for Franklin Amaya, the Panamanian district attorney prosecuting the case.

Advertise with us

Ms. Ridgley has been in custody in Panama City since April 12, two days after a handyman alerted authorities about Ms. Abrams' blood-stained apartment. The living quarters for the two women were connected by an interior spiral staircase.

After Ms. Abrams' remains were discovered, a taxi driver said he had driven Ms. Ridgley and the Colombians to the neighborhood where the suitcase was dumped. Investigators are not certain whether Ms. Ridgley helped burn the remains.

The murder occurred about six weeks after Ms. Ridgley had rented an upstairs apartment from Ms. Abrams while recovering from a facelift in Miami in late February.

"I said, 'Why don't you just [recuperate] down in Miami on South Beach or something,' " said Mr. Barcheski, 64, of Center, who spoke with his ex-wife shortly before her trip. "For some reason she wanted to go to Panama, and I don't know why."

Ms. Abrams was a star student at Carrick High School who went on to financial success in New York after she graduated from the University of Pittsburgh in the early 1970s.

Advertise with us

Her father, Ralph Grossi, was a controversial hypnotist who worked with Hollywood stars and achieved some fame by appearing on nationally broadcast television shows. Her divorced mother, Susan Grossi, was killed in a murder-suicide in 1970 in her Carrick home by the man she was dating.

Ms. Ridgley's family and attorney said the women first met in mid-March when Ms. Ridgley rented an apartment after a previously arranged rental fell through. Others said Ms. Ridgley had already arranged to rent from Ms. Abrams by the time she left for Florida in February.

How did women meet?

"From everyone I've spoken to, no one knows who this Debra Ridgley is. From what we can determine, she didn't have a relationship with Toni, a friendship, nothing. This was a person she rented to, that's it," Mr. Redlich said.

Ms. Abrams visited Panama for the past three or four years to vacation and invest in real estate.

Advertise with us

Ms. Ridgley had been visiting Central America and the Caribbean since she was a child. Her parents owned a nightclub called Ridgley's Supper Club in Montego Bay, Jamaica, and the family frequently returned to Jamaica and other tropical locales even after Ms. Ridgley's father, Don, divorced her mother and remarried. Ms. Ridgley and Mr. Barcheski honeymooned in Jamaica.

But the family's base was in southern Butler County outside Zelienople, where the Ridgleys moved in 1953, three years after Debi was born.

Ms Ridgley was first married when she was 16. The marriage didn't last long, but produced a child, Stacy Lynn, born a few weeks before Ms. Ridgley's 17th birthday. Two years later, Ms. Ridgley had Joseph with Mr. Barcheski, whom she would marry four years later.

Friends described her as a warm-hearted person who never passed up a chance to help a friend or, sometimes, a stranger.

"Honestly, her biggest flaw is being too trustworthy of people," said her friend Ms. Gross. "You could always count on her."

Advertise with us

Ms. Ridgley worked a variety of jobs over the years, including bartender, waitress, beautician and manicurist. Nevertheless, many of her friends have wondered about the source of her income and that of her boyfriend, Mr. Krupowicz.

Court records show both have inherited some money, but not substantial sums, from Mr. Krupowicz's uncle and Ms. Ridgley's aunt and mother.

The couple live in a spacious home in rural Jackson Township on 8.7 landscaped and wooded acres. A garage holds two antique cars and a boat, and a stable has room for three horses. Ms. Ridgley bought the home and property for $90,000 in 1986.

Over the past five years, Ms. Ridgley has taken out two mortgages on the property for $60,000 -- which was paid off -- and $153,400, as well as a $45,000 home equity loan obtained Jan. 12.

Mr. Krupowicz's older brother, Kenneth, calls the spread the "Ponderosa." He described Ms. Ridgley as a "biker chick who does her nails." The couple, who met at a bar, began seeing each other while Ms. Ridgley and her son lived on the second floor of the house in Center she shared with Mr. Barcheski during divorce proceedings.

Advertise with us

Mr. Krupowicz, 48, declined to discuss Ms. Ridgley recently. He said the "FBI and other authorities" had told him not to say anything about the case and added, "I have two old men in here." Ms. Ridgley's 86-year-old father and Mr. Krupowicz's 94-year-old father, John, live with the couple, friends said.

When Ms. Ridgley arrived in Panama City, she brought along her father and 19-year-old granddaughter, Courtney Tislaretz, whom she had spent years raising.

Ms. Tizlaretz quickly began a relationship with "Andres" -- Didier Osorio Garcia -- whom she met on the street one day while running an errand, according to Mr. Ballesteros. Authorities identified Mr. Garcia using cell-phone photographs shot by the teenager.

Panamanian authorities believe there was some sort of relationship between Ms. Ridgley and Mr. Garcia, who continued to visit even after Ms. Tislaretz returned to the United States, but it is unclear whether it was romantic.

Surveillance video

Advertise with us

Police in Panama reportedly have obtained surveillance videos of an inebriated Ms. Ridgley at a Panama City casino, including one instance in which she and Ms. Abrams physically fought. But on the day of Ms. Abrams' death, it was she who was intoxicated, according to Mr. Ballesteros.

Earlier, he said, Ms. Ridgley had invited Ms. Abrams to an art exhibit. Ms. Abrams wasn't ready to leave at the appointed time, but she invited Ms. Ridgley to go to a club later.

"This indicates the two had a good relationship," Mr. Ballesteros said.

When Ms. Ridgley went downstairs to Ms. Abrams' apartment to take her up on the club offer, he said, she found her drunk and agitated. Mr. Ballesteros said Ms. Abrams grabbed his client and began shouting at her before attacking her with a knife.

Just then, Mr. Garcia came down from Ms. Ridgley's apartment to separate the women. Somehow, Ms. Ridgley's hand was cut. Mr. Garcia told Ms. Ridgley to go upstairs and tend to her wound.

Advertise with us

A short time later, the other Colombian, Mr. Castro, whom Ms. Ridgley had seen only once before with Mr. Garcia, surprised her. He ordered her to provide him with a suitcase and remove her clothes, which were bloody from her wounded hand, Mr. Ballesteros said.

After she changed clothes, Mr. Castro ordered Ms. Ridgley onto the elevator, where Mr. Garcia waited with two plastic trash bags, according to Mr. Ballesteros. A taxi took them about 12 miles to a remote area, where the bags and the suitcase containing Ms. Abrams' remains were dumped. Mr. Ballesteros said his client had no idea of their contents.

After that, the Colombians forced Ms. Ridgley to go to a pawn shop, where they sold her earrings and bracelet. They also took money from her wallet, Mr. Ballesteros said.

The next morning, Mr. Ruiz said, the trio went to a cafe and Ms. Ridgley broke down in tears. A waiter noticed and, becoming suspicious, notified a member of the Tourism Police force, who checked on Ms. Ridgley. She said everything was all right. The officer, unaware of the homicide, took down the trio's names, Mr. Ruiz said.

Mr. Ballesteros said the police officer actually ferried the three back to the murder scene, where Ms. Ridgley told the Colombians to leave. He said she went straight to her apartment and fell asleep, unaware of Ms. Abrams' grisly end until the following day.

Advertise with us

Police arrested Ms. Ridgley after they interrogated her at the station, hours after she was questioned in her apartment when police arrived to investigate Ms. Abrams' disappearance.

The prosecutor, Mr. Amaya, filed a homicide charge against Ms. Ridgley and the two fugitive Colombians. Mr. Amaya's office will present evidence to a judge at some point in the future. If found guilty, Ms. Ridgley could be sentenced to at least five to 12 years in prison.

She remains in a holding cell at the police station with other women. Her attorney said last week that she was sad and lonely,

"She's not used to that. She's used to getting her nails done and her hair done and eating in good restaurants. She's not used to six people in a cell," Mr. Barcheski said.

Ms. Ridgley's son talked with her recently and said she's doing as well as can be expected under the circumstances.

Advertise with us

"She's trying to stay positive about the whole situation," Joe Ridgley said. "The conditions are not the best."

Staten Island Advance

Debra Ridgley at Easter last year with her grandchildren, Mason, 3, and Caleb Ridgley, 11 months.

Click photo for larger image.Previous story:

Charges filed in Carrick native's brutal killing in Panama (04/17/07)

Advertise with us

Toni-Grossi Abrams

Click photo for larger image.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.